patching...
Update: Only 2 more "likes" until we reach 1,600! Have you liked Herndon Patch on Facebook yet? If not, you're missing the conversation! CLICK HERE »
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

What Happened to America's Dog?

Pit Bulls were once loved and revered in America. How did they become so maligned in today's society?

 

You may have thought this story would be about a Labrador or Golden Retriever, but it’s about a group of dogs commonly referred to as 'Pit Bulls' and their fall from grace in our society.

During the first half of the 20th century, Pit Bulls were the closest thing the United States had to a national dog.  They were featured on U.S. recruiting posters in World Wars I and II, prominently featured as corporate mascots and cast as the ideal family dog in television and movies.

Now the breed is demonized and battles everything from a media-driven reputation for being predators, to abuse from their owners, to legislation that seeks to outlaw their existence. How did this happen to a dog that was once America’s sweetheart?

WHAT IS A PIT BULL?

The term "Pit Bull" doesn’t describe a single breed of dog; it’s a generic term used to define multiple breeds of working dogs that were initially bred by crossing bulldogs with terriers.  The core breeds include the American Pit Bull Terrier, American Staffordshire Terrier and the Staffordshire Bull Terrier, but the term is now used to encompass a wide array of muscular dogs with short hair, many of which are mixed breeds with a similar look but a different lineage. Dogs commonly mislabeled as pit bulls include Boxers, Mastiffs, American Bulldogs and Plott Hounds, among others. 

For the purposes of this story, "Pit Bull" will be used to describe any mixes, mutts, or purebreds that share either the breed or visual traits common to these dogs, and thus face the stigma. While it’s technically incorrect, this is how it’s used in our vocabulary today.

As a quick test for yourself, see if you’re able to pick out the actual American Pit Bull Terrier from this group of photos.

HISTORY OF PIT BULLS IN AMERICA

It’s believed that the first Pit Bulls were brought to America by English and Irish immigrants before the Civil War. In Europe, the dogs had a mixed history of being used as working dogs to protect the family and field, and misused for savage sports like bull baiting, which was outlawed in the Cruelty to Animals Act of 1835.

When Pit Bulls came to the U.S., they were brought over as prized family possessions, and were typically general purpose herding and working dogs, earning their keep as hunters, herders, guardians and household pets.

By the early 1900s, the Pit Bull was one of the most popular breeds in the U.S., and had become a symbol of American pride. They were used in posters to recruit soldiers and sell war bonds, and a Pit Bull mix named Sgt. Stubby was the first dog to be awarded Army medals. He not only survived being wounded twice in combat, but also saved his entire platoon by warning them of a poison gas attack. Stubby went on to become an American celebrity, meeting three different presidents and becoming the mascot for the Georgetown Hoyas football team.

Pit Bulls were also embraced in popular culture, with respected companies like RCA and the Buster Brown Shoe Company using the Pit Bull as their mascot and in advertising. Petey, the beloved dog with the ring around his eye from The Little Rascals, was also a Pit. Popular figures from this era like Theodore Roosevelt, Laura Ingalls Wilder and Helen Keller were all proud Pit Bull owners. Because of their loyalty and temperament, they even earned the nickname “nanny dogs,” entrusted to watch over and protect children while parents worked on the farm. Pit Bulls were America's sweetheart breed: Admired, respected and loved.

REVERSAL OF FORTUNE

After WWII, the Pit Bull’s popularity began to decline, as other breeds came into favor.  But they were not feared or maligned until the 1980's, when the myth of the dangerous fighting dog started to take hold in the media. The negative publicity surrounding Pit Bulls actually served to encourage bad people with bad intentions to buy and breed these dogs, using brutality and torture to teach fighting and aggression. Gangs began assimilating Pit Bulls into their operations, and the dogs became guilty by association with this violent, criminal culture.

The dogs that are born into and raised in this environment are victims; they are beaten, electrocuted, chained, starved and even fed gunpowder to make them tough and mean. Those that don’t fight back enough are killed or used as bait. They are seen as a form of protection and symbol of strength in these bad communities, and they continue to be exploited for profit in dog fighting, a cruel and sadistic sport that is now illegal in all 50 states.

Through no fault of their own, many dogs are thrown into a very dark world of violence, and face a very difficult road out of it. While these extreme cases are a minority of the Pit Bulls in the country, these brutalized dogs represent the vast majority of dog bites and news stories that contribute to the cycle of sensationalized media coverage, vilifying the dog as inherently aggressive and dangerous.

MEDIA BIAS

The media has been a driving factor in shaping America's perception of Pit Bulls, and their coverage has been widespread and overwhelmingly negative for the last 30 years. The sad truth is that a dog biting a person only becomes a story if there is reason to believe the dog might be a Pit Bull.

Dog attacks involving a Pit Bull-type dog or Pit mix have the power to make national news, while attacks by other breeds go largely unnoticed. In fact, the ASPCA has reported that animal control officers have been told by media outlets across the country that they only have interest in reporting on Pit Bull attacks. Inaccurate reporting is also a problem, and the assumption is often made that muscular, short-haired dogs are Pit Bulls, while those that look different are simply referred to as “dogs.” To compound matters, most organizations that assess dog bite statistics do so based on media accounts, which is already distorted data. It’s a cycle.

If you’re not sure this is true, and you believe Pit Bulls are inherently dangerous, ask yourself how you’ve arrived at that decision. If you haven’t ever seen a Pit Bull be dangerous or aggressive, it’s very likely that the media has defined this perception for you. All dog breeds - including Pit Bulls - bite people. However, try to think of the last story you read where a dog attack involved something other than a Pit Bull. 

FACTS (statistics from the Humane Society and BestFriends.org)

  • In 2007, Pit Bulls were involved in 25 percent of reported dog-abuse cases.
  • About half of the dogs killed in shelters today will be Pit Bulls or Pit Bull mixes.
  • Nationwide, 75 percent of shelters euthanize all Pit Bulls, regardless of temperament, age, history, etc.
  • No breed of dog is inherently aggressive or dangerous.
  • The biggest risk factors for dog aggression are malicious or neglectful dog owners, and dogs that have not been spayed or neutered.
  • Pit Bulls are commonly used in police work, rehabilitation therapy, search and rescue and in bomb and narcotic detection.
  • Like any dog that’s raised responsibly, Pit bulls are gentle, loving and loyal, and they make great family pets.

RESPONSIBLE OWNERSHIP

Pit Bulls are not for everyone, and typically not the best fit for the first-time dog owner. They are intelligent, energetic and strong-willed dogs who need consistent leadership from their owner, a commitment to their training, daily exercise and socialization. Owning any powerful breed of dog comes with this additional responsibility. When you own a Pit Bull, you need to be prepared for negative comments and bias towards your dog, and be ready to educate and address them in a positive way. You must also lead by example and make sure your dog is an ambassador for the breed.

MY PIT PUPS

This was a challenging story to write because it’s personal to me, and there are so many points I want to include. I’m the proud owner of the two Pit Bull pups that you see in the main photo. Both were rescued from abusive situations, and both are the sweetest dogs you will ever meet. 

Cleo was found at nine weeks old, malnourished and abandoned in a sealed box in the middle of the road. She was nurtured back to health by a dedicated rescue organization, and is now a friendly, well-adjusted dog who still trusts and loves unconditionally every human she meets.

Zoe is our newest addition, and as young pup, she is still a work in progress. She was the victim of an animal cruelty case at just three months old, and was offered up for free on Craig’s List by her former owners. Thankfully, a Good Samaritan who knew that Pit pups can easily fall into the wrong hands for the wrong reasons stepped in to save her. She spent the first year of her life in a kennel, so we are working to teach her the typical puppy lessons she hasn’t yet had a chance to learn.

Even though both dogs had tough starts in life, they are good canine citizens: great with other dogs, gentle with children, respectful, smart and a joy to have as part of our family. Pit Bulls are the least likely breed to be adopted, but some of the most loyal and loving dogs you will ever find. Cleo and Zoe are great examples of all the wonderful Pit Bull rescue dogs that need and deserve good homes.

The defamation of Pit Bulls and their portrayal as predators is a man-made problem. They are victims of widespread abuse, and their problems are amplified by sensational media. No dogs are inherently dangerous, but as a strong breed, Pit Bulls do require responsible ownership

If you are interested in adopting one of our amazing resident Pit Pups, go to the Mutts Matter Adoption Page and fill out an application, or if you want to learn more you can contact Suzanne at suzanne@muttsmatterrescue.com

Follow Mutts Matter on Facebook to learn more about us and see new pups coming into the rescue!

Related Topics: Animal Abuse, Animal Cruelty, Dog Adoption, Dogs, Mutts Matter Rescue, Pets, Pit Bull, dog rescue, dog rescue, and pit bulls

Comment_arrow

Marion Tinsley

7:02 am on Friday, August 10, 2012

Its true that any breed can be dangerous. Example Cocker Spaniels always seem to be near the top in biting. However, when a pitbull bits and gets into a biting frenzy the victom whether another dog or a human suffers horrible or fatal wounds sue to the power in the jaws of the pitbull. Pitbulls like Dobermans and other large breeds have been breed to increase their natural aggressive traits and many people who own them make them even more aggressive. And since we cannot control stupidity in america and how those stupid people treat and raise aggressive dogs there are some breeds that should be aggressively controlled. BTW Just so you are aware a few months ago one of these docile animals, in an unprovoked attack, attempted to rip my 3 year old daughters face off. After some plastic surgery surgery she will be fine. Oh and the dog is fine too. Jersy law says neither I or the state can kill it for trying to eat my child. Only if it attacks me or my livestock.

Comment_arrow

Patrick

2:03 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

Remember " There are no bad dogs, Just bad owners."

Comment_arrow

Leonie Alemann

11:56 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

Are pitbulls misunderstood?
No. Most are street-bred mongrels which are backyard-bred by people who have no idea what they are doing. The rest are bred for dog-fighting.
If you want one that is a sound, stable, healthy and trustworthy dog, get an AKC registered American Staffordshire Terrier or Staffordshire Bull Terrier, or a UKC Purple Ribbon Bred American Pit Bull Terrier. Anything else is a mutt with a probable recent ancestry in dog fighting or guarding crack houses. That's just the sad reality of today.
Those who breed for fighting don't care about pedigrees, and these dogs are probably based on APBT and Am Staff, plus part Rottweiler or Cane Corso for power, part Mastiff for size, part Presa Canario or Argentine Dogo for ferocity. These dogs are not suitable as house pets and should be avoided at all costs.
Don't take a puppy from a neighbor who swears the mom and dad are just the sweetest dogs ever... if they aren't show champions with obedience degrees, you're trusting your family's life and safety to the promise if a stranger with no evidence to back it up. Golden Retrievers are, as has been said, notoriously sweet and malleable... but there are still horrible incidents involving vicious Golden Retrievers.

Comment_arrow

melissa heyeck

10:15 am on Thursday, August 16, 2012

Thank you for writing this great article. I am a proud owner of a 'pit bull type dog' who had a rough start to life as well. She is incredibly affectionate, smart and eager to please and so incredibly forgiving. I hope this article changes people's perceptions and encourages people to consider adopting a pitty. They are SO deserving.

Liz Fournier

8:28 am on Thursday, August 9, 2012

Fabulous article! As an owner of two pits, one being a rescue from a really abusive family, I found this article so spot on! Thank you for opening everyones eyes to the stereotypes of this amazing breed. They are truely the most loveable and loyal dogs i've ever had the pleasure of owning.

Reply

Sandra

8:28 am on Thursday, August 9, 2012

Thank for writing this. It is about time more people step up and help to save these beautiful loving dogs.

Your two are beautiful!

Reply

Terrence Dankel

8:36 am on Thursday, August 9, 2012

One hopes that the same Media bias that encouraged miss-representation could be repaired by equal column inches of articles just like this one. Those dogs are influenced by their enviornment and it is humans that control those settings. Go after the humans creating the harmful settings.

Reply

liz ashworth

8:44 am on Thursday, August 9, 2012

Thankyou for taking the time to write this its very powerful.

Reply

Laurie Dodd

8:53 am on Thursday, August 9, 2012

Any breed of dog can be violent. Research has shown that most aggressive dogs have not been spayed or neutered, have not been socialized by lots of human contact, and have often spent too much time tied or chained. When a dog bites a human, there is usually a human to blame.

Reply

Wien

9:47 am on Thursday, August 9, 2012

Agreed 100%, this breed has been mislabeled and misunderstood for far too long. Especially considering that half the people on the street can't even properly identify a pit bull. I have a pit/lab mix and a boxer/lab mix, and both are often mistaken for various breeds...most people just ask "is that a pit bull?" There's a reason an old SPCA magazine labels pit bulls (on the cover no less) as the 'best dog for children.' Breed-based discrimination and legislation is making the dogs out to be the enemy, not the irresponsible owners.

Reply

Loree

10:19 am on Thursday, August 9, 2012

Thank you for writing this article! My husband and I have been pit owners for years and they are wonderful dogs! Thank you! Thank you! Thank you!

Reply

Marie

10:22 am on Thursday, August 9, 2012

Wonderful article, spot on! Breaks my heart how difficult it is to live in this area as a renter and find a place that allows pit bulls. They're the only kind of dog I ever want to own!

Reply

Eliana

10:29 am on Thursday, August 9, 2012

Well written and compelling. You've done a great service to pit bulls and, with this article alone, may save the lives of a number of them.

What really stresses and depresses me is your description of Cleo found in a sealed box in the middle of the road. It only validates my concern every time I drive by a box or Hefty bag at the side of a road/highway. I always wonder if there are pups or kittens in them. It's not always feasible, safe or possible to pull over every time. I have done it on occasion and - thank God - so far it's been trash. But to think there are others that go unnoticed ... horrible.

Again, a wonderful article. I hope it it picked up by other media outlets.

Reply

Kirk Harrod

10:45 am on Thursday, August 9, 2012

I have been attacked by dogs three times in my life. Guess what breed of dog attacked me 2 of the 3 times? Yep, pit bulls or pit bull mixes, I guess you call them. One time, I was walking my dog on leash, and 4 pit bulls used a chair that was beside a fence to jump it and attack me and my border collie. My border collie is ruined. She is terrified to walk on leash and she constantly looks behind her as we walk. She is also afraid of all other dogs now. Another time, my neighbor was jogging with her dog, and 2 pit bulls attacked her and her dog. I saw this happening and was able to get the pits off of her and her dog. I have plenty of bloody pictures that I will post, if you do not believe me.
The fact is, retrievers are bred to retrieve. Shepherds are bred to herd. They do this very well. Pit bulls have been bred (in the last 50 years, as you say) to fight and kill. And they also do it well. They kill cats and little dogs in my neighborhood, causing heartbreak. The pit bulls I have experience with attack other animals instinctively.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Kirk Harrod

10:49 am on Thursday, August 9, 2012

Actually, now that I think about it, I have been bit 4 times, 3 times by pit bulls.

Comment_arrow

Buck

10:57 am on Thursday, August 9, 2012

Are you sure it wasn't 5 times, and 6 by pit bulls?

Comment_arrow

Aka B.

1:26 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

I think you missed the point of the article. It's not saying Pitbulls never bite people- quite the opposite. Pitbulls are famed for biting people, because they are often trained so poorly, due to being popular 'mean' dogs.

Do you know anything about the owners of your neighbourhood pitbulls? I'm going on the assumption that those pit bulls are not socialized or well trained at all, especially if they have so many.

You can also work with your Border collie so she isn't 'ruined'. It will take a long time, but it's up to you, her owner, to make her right again, just like the responsibility of a well-behaved pit bull falls on the owner's shoulders, not the breed.

Comment_arrow

Liz Fournier

1:31 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

Kirk,
It just so happens i've has a few altercations with dogs as well. All of them were German Shepherds. Do i regard the breed of German Shepherds as vicious and bred to "fight and kill"? No. That would be absurd, just like the stereotypes you've just listed for "pit bulls". There are certain reasons dogs react the way that they do, all of it comes down to the humans that train them.

Comment_arrow

Tammy

2:36 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

I and my pit bull type dog were attacked by a Golden Retriever 3 years ago while walking through our neighborhood. My dog was leashed, walking by my side, smelling random items along the way, when out of nowhere a neighbor's Golden Retriever burst through the front door of the house it resided (breaking the screen), ran through the yard, across the street and onto the sidewalk we were on, pursuing us for another 15 feet at which time it leaped in the air and grabbed my pit bull type dog by the neck and began violently thrashing her around and in the process bit me. That is only time I've been bit by a dog. The dog you note as a fact only retrieves, did that alright; it retrieved the neck of my pit bull type dog, causing both physical and emotional injuries to include her extreme fear of any and all dogs that we would encounter while walking. Your experience and mine are unfortunate, however, I decided not to let that incident dictate my opinion of a single breed and had the good sense to know that breed alone does not dictate behavior. As a result, rather then labeling our dog "ruined," as you've described yours, we provided the necessary rehabilitation for our dog to include counter conditioning and positive association training to elicit from her a controlled emotional response at the sight of other dogs in an effort to replace her "bad memories." Our training was a success and fortunately, we did not allow a singular event to stigmatize every Golden we've seen.

Comment_arrow

Rizzle

2:49 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

I'm gonna go ahead and call it, Tammy. That's the biggest load of BS I've ever heard. I'm sure your pitbull cowered and sulked at the thought of the Retriever slashing and sleighing at you. BS.

Comment_arrow

Joe

2:51 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

I've been held up at gunpoint by a 20-something "Black" male in a dense urban area. I don't go around thinking all people who might look of African lineage to be bad people. In the same time frame where racism has sharply declined, hatred towards bully breeds has increased. This leads me to believe the only thing instinctive here is HUMAN hatred.

Comment_arrow

Tammy

3:04 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

@ Rizzle: You can think that if you like, fortunately for me, I have the legal documentation, physical evidence, witness testimony, and animal control reports to support my encounter. After 15 years as a litigator, I never leave any stone unturned nor do I ever present a fact that can't be substantiated by proof. Your short sightedness and trigger-happy attitude to judge will allow you to blindly trust that non-pit bull type dogs won't bite and to blantanly ignore behavioral warning signs in any dog signifying a potential to bite and will sadly result in you possibly sustaining a dog bit too.

Comment_arrow

Wien

4:12 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

My pit mix is afraid of everything that makes the slightest noise, he's a complete wuss. So to say it's BS that a pit bull could be scared of a retriever is sheer silliness...in fact, most big dogs I've owned have always been scared, or at least taken aback, by some of smaller, more aggressive dogs. The only reason you don't hear about smaller dogs biting everyone is because they do no damage, so no one cares.

As far as the person who claims they've been bitten by 5 or 6 dogs...I'd suggest you do something else around them, or move to a neighborhood that doesn't have roving packs of dogs...because that isn't normal. Although I'd be willing to bet they couldn't properly identify a pit bull, as indicated by everyone asking if my boxer mix is a pit bull.

Comment_arrow

JB

9:46 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

For the poster calling BS that a golden retriever would attack another dog (or anything else for that matter), I call BS on that. It was around 6 years ago that a golden retriever in the area I lived in ripped a newborn baby apart as it lay in its swing basonet. The mother was all over the news, not able to believe her family dog had done that in the few minutes she left the room to answer the phone.

Comment_arrow

Jason

10:04 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

Aggression studies performed by researchers have concluded quite the opposite:
http://www.nationalcanineresearchcouncil.com/blog/new-study-finds-banned-breeds-no-more-aggressive-than-any-others/

I wonder who will ignore this data since it conflicts with their confirmation bias? Josh and others have asked for data and now they have it.

There are also studies performed by professional animal behaviorists which confirm these scientific studies. However, I didn't feel the need to dig those up since the dogbites.org data has many flaws as pointed out by others.

Comment_arrow

CareInn

11:38 am on Friday, August 10, 2012

I'm truly sorry for your horrible experiences with the breed. Granted that is all you have known, do you really not feel at all ignorant basing an opinion of an entire breed on an interaction with a few?! Have you met others? I am floored at how people have one bad experience and judge them all. Have you ever had an unpleasant encounter with a white/black/hispanic person?! Do you think that they are all bad because of one or a few?!? C'mon people. I'm a Pit owner and lover as well and have volunteered with the organization that this article is attributed to and while I love the breed I believe that there are some pitbulls that need to be put down because of their aggression however there are also golden retrievers, malteses, and miniature terriers that need to as well. If you had been attacked by two cocker spaniels would you be in favor of destroying the whole breed? I seriously doubt it. My brother has been a victim of a dog attack, and guess what IT WASN"T A PITBULL. Dogs are animals. They are unpredictable and sometimes vicious. They can't tell us they are irritated or threatened by a situation. They use their mouths to express themselves. Again, I'm sorry for your experience but also your prejudice tendencies.

Comment_arrow

Christina Mays

1:10 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

Kirk,
First I would say sorry for your experiences. You might consider getting animal control out there to control the roving packs of dogs. That isn't a good situation no matter what the breed. What you appear to have is very bad owners. Any dog that is untrained, unsocialized, and in the hands of irresponsible owners can be dangerous. I've been attacked many times (I have worked with dogs as a shelter volunteer and I have done animal rescue for years) and it's never been deliberately by a pit. I have been bitten by a Sheppard mix, a Saint Bernard, a Bishon, and several other small dog mixes. My dogs were attacked (unprovoked) by a Golden. I don't hold any of those breeds responsible, I hold those irresponsible owners responsible. You have had a bad experience, that is true but your bias is against an entire breed and that is just ridiculous. That is like saying because you were in a car accident, all cars should be taken off the road. It isn't the car, it is the person driving it.
BTW, yes, some people do breed pits to fight and kill. That is a very small percentage of the entire breed. You overgeneralize.

Comment_arrow

Patrick

1:53 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

You Can not blame the dog! There are no bad dogs, just bad owners.
"Judge the deed, not the breed" Having owned both pit bulls and rottweilers for almost 28 years, I've never had a problem, training and socialization, is the key.

Josh Smith

10:57 am on Thursday, August 9, 2012

Unfortunately, I disagree with each and every one of you. A study was done looking at all dog attacks that maimed or killed humans from 1982 through 2011 (including US and Canada) by an editor of 'Animal People'. In that study it was found that Pit Bull terriers and other breeds of Pit Bulls are the most violent dogs around.

Regardless of how much you love your Pit, they are a dangerous breed. http://www.dogsbite.org/dog-bite-statistics-study-dog-attacks-and-maimings-merritt-clifton.php

Reply
Comment_arrow

ArnoldZiffel

11:00 am on Thursday, August 9, 2012

Oh, you're just being silly. it couldn't be the beloved pit bulls you are talking about.

Comment_arrow

Buck

11:10 am on Thursday, August 9, 2012

this would be compelling if dogsbite.org weren't a sham or had credible data. it also seems to be the only site people like you can link to. wonder why that is?

Comment_arrow

Josh Smith

11:18 am on Thursday, August 9, 2012

Well Buck, I presented actual data and factual information...where's yours?

Comment_arrow

Buck

11:25 am on Thursday, August 9, 2012

no, you posted a website run by one person with an agenda who fabricates data. how about the CDC: http://www.cdc.gov/HomeandRecreationalSafety/Dog-Bites/dogbite-factsheet.html

also, congratulations on making yourself an example of what the article was about.

Comment_arrow

Josh Smith

11:49 am on Thursday, August 9, 2012

From the very link you posted: "A CDC study on fatal dog bites lists the breeds involved in fatal attacks over 20 years (Breeds of dogs involved in fatal human attacks in the United States between 1979 and 1998 ). It does not identify specific breeds that are most likely to bite or kill, and thus is not appropriate for policy-making decisions related to the topic."

Try again.

Comment_arrow

Rizzle

11:54 am on Thursday, August 9, 2012

Buck, congratulations on being yet another delusional Pit bull owner who didn't even read the article he used to justify his argument, while belittling others. You sound like a true pitbull owner.. Taken from your article: "As in recent years, Rottweilers were the most commonly reported breed involved in fatal attacks, followed by pit bull-type dogs (Table 1). Together, these2 breeds were involved in approximately 60% of human deaths."

Comment_arrow

Clay Hund

12:04 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

Um, Josh, please go back and look at dogsbite. Is there anything unusual about that website to you? It is a horrible source of information and biased as can be. The founder of that website is very anti-pit bull and gets paid to write all of that nonsense. She is a website designer and knows zilch about dogs. she claims she was bittne by a a dog back in 2007 by what she believes was a pit bull and is actually unsure, as many dogs resemble pit bulls, are called pit bulls, but are actually completely different breeds or mutts. And the study she uses by merritt clifton is nonsense as well. Merritt is NOT an canine expert in any way at all, but rather a reporter that concocted that study. he is also anti-pit bull. The internet is a wonderful source of information, but you have to be able to decipher the real from the baloney. Not one canine expert or reputable canine organization agrees with anything the dogbite or merritt clifton has to say. Do yourself a favor and get some experience with pit bulls or a professional opinion, such as a veterinarian or canine behaviorist, rather than learning from hearsy and wicked biased websites full of propaganda. When you cite a source like dogsbite, you are showing that you are completely ignorant on this topic and you are taken with a grain of salt. Please, do your homework and seek out good information, if not gain some first hand experience, before making a judgement. A pit bull is no more dangerous than a german shepherd or large lab.

Comment_arrow

Rizzle

12:07 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

Clay, I encourage you to read the CDC article that our other delusional friend, Buck , so kindly listed. It seems to be a reputable source. It claims Rots and Pits are to blame for 60% of human fatalities in dog attacks. Read the PDF within the article.

Comment_arrow

Bex Allen

12:24 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

The CDC study has long been debunked by several organizations. Just read the limitations section.

Comment_arrow

Rizzle

12:26 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

Several special interest organizations, yes. Believe what you will.. because you're going to anyways. Me however... After what I've seen, I jog with my gun and CHL now.

Comment_arrow

Josh Smith

12:27 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

Typical responses. Dismiss every piece of factual information presented as bogus because you don't agree with it. I hope against hope you don't regret your decision to own a vicious, violent dog breed.

Comment_arrow

Aka B.

1:29 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

Again, I mentioned to another person, I think you may have missed the point of the article. It's not saying that pitbulls don't bite a lot of people. It's saying that it's not the breed's fault- many people want a scary, mean dog, and pitbulls unfortunately fit the bill, so they are treated innappropriately and turn nasty. Any other dog will do that if treated the same way, it's just that pitbulls are the usual targets.

Comment_arrow

Wien

4:20 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

The question is how these studies are conducted. The ASPCA has shown that news organizations and law enforcement misidentify pit bulls in a significant portion of reports...so what does that do to the data? Is the data based on identification by vets? Is it based on news reports and witness accounts? Is it per capita, is it geographic, what's the threshold for inclusion? Point is, I can find a website with "factual" statistics to prove pretty much anything I want.

Even taking the study as complete truth and saying that pit bulls caused more injuries than any other breeds...what is the conclusion to draw? Most deaths from terrorism are due to Muslims, does that make all Muslims terrorists? Should we introduce legislation to ban them or should we not rent to them? But what about acts (not deaths)...an overwhelming percentage of terrorist actions in the USA are from white Christians...should we introduce religion-based legislation to discriminate there?

No, that would be stupid. Breed-based legislation, especially for a breed misidentified with abandon, does nothing but punish the large faction of outstanding dog owners. Just like religion-based legislation would do nothing but punish the large portion of responsible Muslims and Christians. But hey, "all" attacks are from pit bulls...so all pit bulls must be attackers.

Comment_arrow

xtreg

10:24 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

Josh is right. This article is propaganda. Even if I concede that pitbulls are no more violent than any other breed, the jaws of a pitbull are far more powerful than the jaws of any other breed I am aware of. Consequently, the bite of a pitbull is far more damaging.There's a reason that the dogs used for fighting are pitbulls and not beagles or poodles.

Comment_arrow

Buck

11:10 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

you do a lot of comparative bite pressure measurement, xtreg? what's your PhD in, and what kind of methodology do you use?

Comment_arrow

CareInn

11:42 am on Friday, August 10, 2012

Do you honestly think that people who are bit always report it? If a miniature breed of dog attacks you, you have the ability to kick or push it away. Why report that? You have to realize if that dog was bigger then it would do more damage however the underlying issue is still aggression towards humans and/or dogs. And the website you reference must be taken in context. Look at the percentage of the dog population that pitbulls are. An exceedingly higher rate than any other. Multiply it accordingly and it's not nearly as shocking a number for Pits.

Comment_arrow

Christina Mays

1:13 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

Did you ask where they get the material for their stats? They studies are flawed because they are one sided. There have been tons of studies done that say different things. You can always skew a study to come out the way your bias leans. You should know that.

Comment_arrow

Susan Warner

7:50 pm on Thursday, August 16, 2012

dogsbite.org is the most biased, anti-pit sites on the web. Their site is full of horrible, negative reporting..... not credible at all.

Elyse

11:08 am on Thursday, August 9, 2012

I had a gorgeous blue pit, she was only two and just the sweetest little girl. We had three other dogs already when we got her as a pup, two small rescue dogs and an older lab. She became our family and like our others was a member of it getting the comfort of the beds at night local walks and lots of treats. She never showed on ounce of any type of aggressive behavior, attitude, or made us feel our two little ones were in danger. One night just like any other she just snapped and maliciously, brutally attacked and killed one of our small female dogs. It was devastating for me and my family and a horrible tragic event that hasn't left our minds. We lost trust in her that she wouldn't do something like this again to another dog or a human. We never hated her and was with her from the very end staying with her showing love towards her, even to this day my family and I do not hate her and do not look at all "pit-bulls" as evil dangerous dogs. We lost two family members that weekend, two very beloved family members, both will forever be in our hearts. Every dog deserves a chance to find the right home and you cannot base one innocent pit bull based on from what you hear, they are not born evil and do not deserve to be punished based on a biased stereotype against them. R.i.p saphira and krumbl

Reply
Comment_arrow

CareInn

11:52 am on Friday, August 10, 2012

I believe you might be the most intelligent, non-biased person to have responded to this article. Thank you. To everyone else, read this and understand the message: YOU CANNOT BASE AN OPINION OF AN ENTIRE BREED BASED ON ANY ONE OR (as the bogus article referrenced above states) 1066 INDIVIDUAL DOGS! Again, you don't know what situations/triggers can provoke a dog to "snap" because they cannot tell us they feel scared, threatened or aggrivated. They are animals, they don't think they just react. It's called INSTINCT

bill s

11:09 am on Thursday, August 9, 2012

I'm sure you're right about pit bulls being vilified in the media. Why people choose to use pit bulls as aggressors is because they have the physical equipment to do the job. I'd just as soon not take the chance that your dog is harmless. How about owners being required to watch as a surgeon puts some kid's face back together?

Reply
Comment_arrow

Wien

4:33 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

Should every motorcycle owner be required to watch a surgeon put back together an accident victim? Should every gun owner be required to watch a surgeon put some kid's face back together?

Pit bulls have the physical equipment to kill...so do half the devices in your house and all the distracted drivers on the road in Northern Virginia.

Sally Spangler

11:16 am on Thursday, August 9, 2012

The original - Pit Bull Terrier - was bred for fighting. A way back there, but that is history. Pit - a circular space, I have idea how big. Bull - male bovine with horns and a short temper. Go back to at least the beginning of the 19th Century. The dog would be put in to fight the bull. Both were not long at it before one or bother would be bloodied and either badly injured or dead. The owner of the still living animal wold collect his bet money. and the next dog versus bull would be put in the fighting area to fight.. The same between game cocks, specially bred roosters to fight each other. I know this is illegal today. But - if you look around carefully there may be cock fighting places.
So - after many generations of breeding dogs to fight - the dogs themselves have a certain amount of this bred into their systems and the dogs are edgy. Leave them alone. There are others who are only "pets" They many not want people walking up to them to make comments and pet. The dog may have somethng to say about that. Leave them alone. Chows are another breed who do not like casual touching. Don't see many chows these days. Doberman Pinchers do/did not like casual touching. Dobermans were bred for hunting. Never try to touch a strange dog without the owners permission. Teach your children that lesson. May save a dog bite.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Wien

4:29 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

Pit bulls are loyal and trainable, very disciplined, and aim to please...which is exactly why they were used as US service dogs in World War II. Of course, the flip side to that coin is that their aim to please and be loyal will also extend to the idiots (Michael Vick) who breed them to fight or breed them to protect property by biting.

You should obviously never try to pet or touch a strange dog - no matter the breed. But to say a pit bull is naturally "edgy" or bred to be a fighter is to discount the years of history of using them as service dogs, therapy dogs, and would discount their reputation among the ASPCA and dog groups as being great with children. Their aim to please and loyalty is the key factor - you can raise your dog to use that in a positive way or a negative way.

Interesting that of all of Michael Vick's pit bulls, which were raised to fight, almost all of them were successfully rehabilitated and have lived incident-free with new families or foster families -- sound like a naturally edgy animal who has an inherent flaw in their breeding to kill humans?

Kim Shumaker

11:22 am on Thursday, August 9, 2012

I enjoyed your article very much and wanted to pass along a note about a friend and author, Ken Foster, who runs a Pit Bull Rescue in New Orleans The Sula Foundation and has a new book coming out called I'm a Good Dog !https://www.facebook.com/#!/pages/Im-a-Good-Dog/327408317303102. He'll be on his book tour with a stop in Baltimore at Atomic Books in November 9th and could use some Pitty Support.

Reply

JHS

11:23 am on Thursday, August 9, 2012

Kirk I'm sorry you had many bad experiences with "pit bulls." But if you were mugged 3 times by xxx ethnicity are you going to say that all xxx ethnicity members are muggers? Or might there be other factors involved (such as upbringing, social status quo, education, etc)?

I have worked almost exclusively with "pit bulls" over the past 20 years. I was bitten by a Jindo and a Dalmation and my own AmStaff was bitten by a collie and a malamute (he did not bite back). Statistically, I should have more pit bull attacks in my history since I've been surrounded by them.

I think that it's more of a testament to the breeds that they don't do more damage, considering the abuse and stupid/ignorant people who are drawn to them for media-hyped reasons. They're strong, smart dogs. They are exceptionally loving and humorous characters. Yes, they can be twisted into doing wrong. But it's not because they are "pit bulls." Like children, dogs are the product of their environment and the people who raise them.

Reply

Skitter

11:33 am on Thursday, August 9, 2012

Nobody argues that dogs bred to herd, to retrieve, to swim, etc., don't do what their breed has been selected for. Of course they do (just try keeping a Labrador out of any body of water bigger than a puddle). Yet somehow, this is supposed to be different for dogs that have been bred to attack and kill. Some people want everyone to believe that behaviors like aggression can only be taught, not bred in like loving water or rounding up anything that moves. When someone is unwilling to admit that their favorite breed's defining characteristic is just as innate to that breed as herding is to a sheepdog, I can't accept their objectivity on anything else.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Joe A.

8:28 am on Friday, August 10, 2012

Skitter, I would love your help with my Lab I want him to go swimming in the pool but he has no interest. I have managed to get him to sit near the pool but if he gets wet he moves further away. I am hoping with some training I can change that. As for pit bulls I have never had one though I know several people that have and they have all been wonderful playful dogs. Granted all of them had responsible owners that trained them and exercised them regularly. Having said that would I be afraid of an uncontrolled Pit Bull coming at me absolutely of course I would also be scarred of an uncontrolled Lab coming at me and I have had Labs my whole life. I don’t believe it is appropriate to label all dogs of certain bread as bad and I think it is extremely unfair to always assume the dog is to blame. In any attack all factors need to be considered did the person that was attacked provoke it, was the dog abused, or is the dog inherently bad. Kind of like when humans are put on trial.

Comment_arrow

Erica

3:51 am on Saturday, August 11, 2012

Skitter, your analysis might be sound if we were in fact talking about a breed of dog here. However, we're not. "Pit Bull" is not a breed of dog- it is a label used to describe physical attributes that MANY dogs, mostly mutts, present. In today's overcrowded shelter system, so many dogs that have short coats, boxy heads, square shoulders and are muscular are labeled as "Pit Bulls" or "Pit Mixes". Unless you run DNA on a dog (or it's AKC registered with proven lineage), you don't know its true makeup (and yes, you can have DNA analysis complied on your dogs to find out their true makeup, as opposed to what people guess from their outward appearances). I fostered a stray dog who, from the outside, would fall into the "Pit Bull" category. When I would walk her around town, people would often ask me what type of dog she was. My answer? "I don't know. She was a stray- a mutt of some sort". I was not going to label her as a fictitious breed- a "Pit Bull"- when I had no sound evidence of her being such.
What do you think about Staffies and other real breeds that were bred as family dogs, even nannies, that look like what we today call "Pit Bulls", and because of this are now seen as vicious attack dogs?
I highly suggest you check out: https://www.facebook.com/animalfarmfoundation

Rizzle

11:39 am on Thursday, August 9, 2012

First, Pits are good and loyal dogs. They have their place in society though and it has to be a loving home. That's not to say that a pit won't turn on you. I've been a victim of a pitbull attack in a park. My uncles pitbull turned on him after 14 great years. My nephew had his face chewed on by a loose pitbull when he was 8. My girlfriends mom raises thoroughbred horses. Her neighbors 3 pitbulls escaped and killed all of her horses on a bloody rampage. One was found floating chewed at the neck and stomach in the middle of the stock pond. Would 3 rampaging chihuahuas do this? Would a pack of Labradors do this? There is a reason the shelters are filled with Pitbulls. There is a reason a so called "Myth" surrounds them. There is a reason they are no longer Americas 'Sweetheart' dog. That reason is because as time went on these attacks happened more and more and Americans realized what they are dealing with. Well.. Most people realized, except for those delusional 'Dog Parents' that swear their kids would never do wrong. That's what the owner of the Pit that attacked me said. "He normally so sweet". I was simply jogging by on a running trail. Be responsible people.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Buck

3:43 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

this sounds totally true and believable, "Rizzle". can't wait for your next comment, bro!

Comment_arrow

Rizzle

3:47 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

Still ignoring the Facts that were posted the last time you wrote something? What did you do just go to some other post and bring attention to it to take the focus off of true facts that you have zero rebuttal for? Can't wait to see what you post next tough guy.

Comment_arrow

Buck

4:27 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

looks like we've got an internet badass on our hands here

Comment_arrow

Wien

4:41 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

"There is a reason they are no longer Americas 'Sweetheart' dog. That reason is because as time went on these attacks happened more and more and Americans realized what they are dealing with. "

So you're saying that attacks are happening more and more...even though the population of pit bulls and the occurrence of pit bull ownership has been declining? Did the dogs wake up one day and realize they're "bred to be fighters" as people on here continuously claim?

Or could it be the internet and sensationalist media, combined with the continual misidentification of the breed, are leading to a stigma where every attack is a pit bull? There's a reason everyone asks it my boxer mix is a pit bull - because he's 65 pounds and every Joe on the street thinks a large short-haired dog is a pit bull. Everyone asks if my lab/pit mix is a pit and people even asked if my former lab/ridgeback mix was a pit bull - so I wouldn't put much stock in what people think about a breed they can't even identify.

Samuel Silver

12:50 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

Here's what it comes down to. I have known nice dogs and aggressive dogs, the nice dogs come from nice owners and the aggressive dogs come from bad owners (for clarification bad doesn't necessarily mean 'people who train dogs to fight' it means people who do not train their dogs correctly or give them the type of environment that dogs need.) What people don't always see is the vicious cycle that goes on with pit bulls. Let's say in the 80's the media started printing the 'Pitbulls strike again!' articles. People will believe that. Simple. The cycle starts when jerks and stupid people respond to that article and say, "Yeah! i want a dog that's tough and mean and scary! ill get a pitbull!" Those people become bad owners which leads to aggressive dogs. The media can then turn around and say, "Look Look! See the aggressive pit bull! I told you they were monsters!" and the process begins anew. I've worked for the last year and a half at a dog shelter with abused, neglected, and/or poorly trained dogs. Some were pit bulls with serious behavioral issues, some were pit bulls who were easily as pie, and some still were labs, border collies, sheppards, and many small breed dogs with the same issues. As much as people think they are saving lives by enacting BSL's, the truth of the matter is that people are still going to get bit by dogs as long as their owners don't care for them responsibly.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Rizzle

12:58 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

Except for the fact that Pits still act out with good owners too. All it takes is one small trigger for the pit to go right back to it's roots. Those orangutang owners in California, who gave a loving home for decades, til the orangutangs saw an opening for freedom, killed the owner. Point is a Shark is a shark, an orangutang is an orangutang and a PitBull is a Pitbull. It doesn't take much, no matter much love it's been given in it's life, to have something trigger it's natural instincts. The Pit that attacked me and latched on to my hip like I was a steak, actually seemed sweet. It was on a leash being walked around a park by it's owner. I was jogging by and it happened to turn around the exact moment I ran by. It may have thought I was attacking his owner or running up aggressively for just a split second. Then it reacted. The owners says "He's normally such a kind dog". A 'Kind dog' that would have pulled out my intestines had it latched on to my stomach rather than my pelvic bone. Be a loving AND smart people, not a stupid people..

Comment_arrow

Samuel Silver

6:28 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

I disagree Rizzle. Breed specific legislation has been tried in many places and there is no (Read: Zero) evidence that they increase the safety of the public. First off, scientifically speaking, there is a 1 in 25 million chance that someone will be the victim of what is classified as a severe dog bite. I'm not saying your attack wasn't severe and probably traumatizing, but this isn't a pitbull problem. The owners of the dog that bit you failed the dog by not training it better or if it was an untrained dog they put it in a situation where it would fail. I hope that one day you give the breed a second chance.

Comment_arrow

CareInn

12:11 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

Animals are unpredictable. You said yourself "a shark is a shark, an oragnutang is an oragnutang, and a pitbull is a pitbull". An animal is an animal. Any one breed, species or type of animal can react instintively at any time. The issue is, the bigger the animal, the more potential damage and the less potential a human can control it. Responsible ownership is the key, not elimination of an entire breed. Are you at least able to agree about that Rizzle?

X

12:58 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

Cool story bro. Tell it again.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Kathy

9:24 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

I am guessing there is NOTHING "sweet" about you Rizzle. If a Pitbull "latched" on to you, I feel certain he would have spit you out.

David Close

12:59 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

I said this on FB, I'll say it here too... I get burned up every time I hear about Pit Bulls being targeted as a breed in general. I know several people with Pit Bulls as pets and they are just as friendly and loving and affectionate as my chocolate lab. There has been such a stand AGAINST Pit Bulls that it's time to turn it around and stand-up FOR them! It's all in how they're trained! Even my Choc Lab could have been trained as a dangerous dog. Every breed has their stereotype whether Pit Bull, German Shepherd, Rottweiler, etc. If we as a human race are to love our brother/sister regardless of race, color, religion, or sexual orientation, then we need to start doing the same for our animals!

*SIGH*

Stepping down off my soapbox now.

Reply

Mary's Critter Care

1:41 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

Pits & Rotties are great loyal dogs .. it's bad owners who should be demonized

Reply

Dog rescuer

1:45 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

Samuel, bravo and very well put! At the end of the day, it's the irresponsible/uneducated dog owners that are the issue....not the breed itself. Hold dog owners responsible for not properly socializing and training their dogs....not ban a breed since that doesn't solve the root issue...IRRESPONSIBLE DOG OWNERS!

Reply
Comment_arrow

Skitter

3:44 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

Irresponsible Chihuahua owners don't put the lives of other people at risk. Irresponsible "pit bull" (however you want to define it) owners do. The LIVES of innocent people (and their dogs, for that matter) are what matters here.

Comment_arrow

Wien

4:51 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

To reply to Skitter, irresponsible gun and car owners also put others lives at risk. Doesn't that also matter here? What about horse owners? Let's play "fun with statistics" and show the numbers of injuries and deaths that occur from horses (hint: it's higher than dogs). If we're going to ban things based on the irresponsible few, let's go ahead and ban cars, guns, horses, and even mosques and churches.

Kate W.

1:53 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

It's all about the training and socialization as to how an individual dog will behave. Any dog breed can become aggressive and any dog breed can be sweet as pie. And frankly, in terms of disposition bully breeds are generally very friendly and lovable. Those of you who are terrified of all 'pit bulls' likely don't actually know any in real life (and saying you were attacked by a random dog doesn't mean you knew them). My pup is an American Bulldog and is often mistaken for a pitbull. He is the model at our training class for behavior and disposition over the labs, collies, shepherds, etc. Share the love and rescue a dog - get to know a bully!

Reply

Bentley's BARKery

2:32 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

Thanks, Suzanne, for a well-written article. My late Treeing Walker Coonhound/German Shepherd mix has been my only dog to bite someone and she thought she was being protective of my husband (someone who lived in the neighborhood but we did not know went to put his hand on my husband's shoulder and that's when Kelly bit the gentleman's hand). If Kelly had been a pittie, she would have been deemed a vicious dog. Having met and spent time with Ellen, one of the dogs from Michael Vick's Bad Newz Kennels, she was one of the sweetest most loving dogs of any breeds I have ever met. Judge the dog individually, not the breed.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Wien

4:49 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

What data? There's enough on both sides. Statistics and data solves nothing. Unless you also want to ban cars and guns. Or maybe we should ban horses and donkeys, which are more likely to kill a human than a pit bull on per capita encounters.

Ralph Peters

3:20 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

Fans of pit bulls might want to take a look at "I'm a Good Dog," a new book by Ken Foster. http://www.kenfoster.blogspot.com/

Reply

Cliffie

3:32 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

Our local neighborhodd pit bull is frightened of my rescued beagle. That's because my beagle (known as a sweet family breed) is way meaner than he is! Anytime a human mistreats a dog, it can become aggressive (take it from me, owner of my own personal attack beagle). The sad fact is that pitties get abused all the time by people who want them to fight/protect.

You can't judge an entire breed by a single dog. Especially abused dogs (like a lot of poor pitties and my beagle)

Reply

Jane Blume

3:53 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

I adopted my pitbull 14 years ago when I found her (actually, I think she found me) wandering - collarless - on Four Year Drive. At first I thought she was a Jack Russell Terrier but when I took her to the vet, they told me she was a pit bull (American Staffordshire Terrier). Before that, I didn't know what a pit bull was or that they had a bad rap. Lilly has been a wonderful pet - smart, playful, obedient. Yes, she has had skirmishes with other dogs but has never been aggressive or mean to any person she has ever met. She's 14 now and cute as ever - just a little slower and she doesn't hear so well.

Reply

Skip Endale

4:23 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

Every breed has degenerative tendencies. From what I know the pitbull by nature is not any more aggressive than any other dog. My aunt has one, and she had pups too. No incidents. No lock jaw. Our german sheperd was much more frightening and fierce. Before you get a dog you should determine what purpose it will serve. If you're never home and don't have time for another baby around the house then get yourself a teddy bear. With or without retractable leash

Reply

Wien

4:46 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

I find it funny that half the people on here think we should ban pit bulls because irresponsible pit bull owners put the lives of others at risk. Would those same people be in favor of banning guns or banning cars? What if the statistics showed that per capita, a gun (hint) or a car is more likely to result in a death?

Reply

Sarah

4:54 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

Love it!! We also have a pitbull. She was gift for my little girl when she turned four. She's now 10. They have been best friends since the first day. We constantly have her around kids and all breeds of dogs big and small and she is the best dog we have ever had.

Reply

Linda Gil

7:48 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

For those of you who love statistics, you are much more likely to be hit by lightning than to be killed by a pitbull.
I have two rescued pitties, one had a horrible life before I adopted him 9 years ago. The other is a sweet as pie shelter dog who helps me with my foster cats.

Reply

linda gil

7:48 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

For those of you who love statistics, you are much more likely to be hit by lightning than to be killed by a pitbull.
I have two rescued pitties, one had a horrible life before I adopted him 9 years ago. The other is a sweet as pie shelter dog who helps me with my foster cats.

Reply

Elaine Nixon

8:29 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

Dear friends
I had a very dominant Black Lab who was raised without boundaries (which is why they gave him to me-they'd always had cats. I had never had a dog look me in the eyes, and refuse, but this one did. He tried to bite my husband while getting sprayed for fleas, and my husband smacked him as a reflex, so he respected my husband, but not me. He was grossly overweight, so I trained him with peanuts, which he loved. It took about a year, but he was a smart dog and loved training and learning, and he got to be a very good dog. He llearned pretty quickly that he got no reward unless he obeyed commands, and he loved peanuts, and he loved me. He got up and met me at the door every day, and was so happy to see me. He was 14 when we lost him, and he learned to love me. My son's Rottweiler was sweeter and better-behaved than my Black Lab initially. A lot depends on the dog's individual personality and training. Any dog will bite and it depends on training and the dog's age. Smaller dogs bite quickly when they feel threatened, and a lot of dogs get irritable as they age.

Reply

Robert Haskins

8:46 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

Take a moment to think back a bit. The Doberman, Rottweiler, German Shepherds...all are very powerful animals. Remember they are ANIMALS FIRST! It is the owner's responsibility to understand/read their animal's behaviors. They can then understand their dog's behaviors and finally the breed itself. I was a K-9 Handler with a German Shepherd for about 8 yrs. I was trained at the same time my dog was trained. We developed as a team...over time. Dogs do not communicate in the same ways that we do. A quick eye movement, ears pulled forward, breathing through nose with mouth closed, etc. If you don't recognize the signs your dog is exhibiting, the unwanted behavior will not only continue but may escalate. Some pet owners reinforce bad behaviors without knowing it.

I have seen and been bitten by several small dogs. No one says anything because the injury is minimal. Take a large breed (like my former German Shepherd), when ordered to apprehend/bite someone (by me only) the bite was more severe. There was no pushing him off (he weighed over 75 lbs). My dog also stopped biting immediately upon command...period. He was still an animal...a dog!! It was my job to watch him. If he "targeted" someone/something I immediately had to correct it before it was a problem.

Too many owners have powerful dogs and have no idea how to read the dog and correct him/her before an attack occurs. All dogs have teeth and can bite. People are the problem WAKE UP!

Reply

Elaine Nixon

9:27 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

I' m a Mother and a Grandmother, and I believe it's important for us to teach our children how to approach dogs. My son used to call our Black Lab over to serve as his pillow while he watched TV, and that very compliant dog did just that. My original Black Lab was tuned into me and loved me without reservation.
I grew up with an English Cocker Spaniel who was tuned in to my Mother even more than even she realized. He loved her without reservation, but he was kind of crazy, and would suddenly bark at innocuous objects like a mop leaning against a wall, for no reason. He would protect us and the house against anyone, and it was a good thing we moved so much, because he'd have been declared a dangerous dog today.
I taught my grandsons how to approach dogs, and I was always there when my grandsons and dogs interacted to protect both of them. I'm a nurse and I've seen horrible injuries when dogs attack children. Kids don't read dog behavior well, and they're impulsive. The adults need to train dogs well, train kids well, and to be there while they interact.

Reply

Curveball

11:00 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

You can spin all you want, and commenters can say all they want about it being the owner, not the dog, who causes problems
But the statistics -- national statistics on dog bite attacks and fatal dog bite attacks show that far and away pit bulls are responsible for the most and the worst. You elide what they were bred to do.
So others here might just look it up.
But hey, deal with this hard fact from medical experts: "Attacks by pit bulls are associated with higher morbidity rates, higher hospital charges, and a higher risk of death than are attacks by other breeds of dogs. Strict regulation of pit bulls may substantially reduce the US mortality rates related to dog bites." (Bini, John K.; Cohn, Stephen M.; Acosta, Shirley M.; McFarland, Marilyn J.; Muir, Mark T.; Michalek, Joel E. (2011). "Mortality, Mauling, and Maiming by Vicious Dogs". Annals of Surgery (Lippincott Williams & Wilkins)
I'd rather see you walking down the street with a saw-off shotgun than with a pit bull on a leash. I can more easily assume you might be able to control the shotgun.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Buck

11:33 pm on Thursday, August 9, 2012

accidental gun deaths by children alone is far higher than the number of deaths by all dogs put together. it's a factor of more than 10 for all accidental gun deaths. if we add homicides, the numbers really get going.

you don't know anything, and you write like someone who can't read.

Comment_arrow

Bill Jones

7:33 am on Friday, August 10, 2012

"accidental gun deaths by children alone is far higher than the number of deaths by all dogs put together."

That certainly is a problem. But that is not the subject of this article/thread. The subject is pit bull attacks, which are far too common.

I suppose we could talk about the high number of teen deaths in automobiles. That is another problem. But it is irrelevant to the subject at hand. Or we could talk about bathroom falls. I don' know the number but I bet more injuries are caused by bahroom falls. I can think of other hazzards, but like accidental gun deaths of children, they would be irrelevant.

To cite some other peril in our world is common for pit bull owners/defenders and it shows the level of reasoning power of the people who defend these vicious beasts in the face of the overwhelming, countervailing facts.

Comment_arrow

Cliffie

9:45 am on Friday, August 10, 2012

Just as a point of reference, the subject of this article is not "Pit Bull attacks". It's how misunderstood the breed is.

Also as a point of reference, all the things you mention in your post (bathroom falls, gun deaths, etc.) are far more dangerous than pit bulls. They are popping up in the comments as statistical counterpoints (a common and well regarded debate technique) to the argument that pit bull attacks are a big problem in this country.

Robert Haskins

12:20 am on Friday, August 10, 2012

Curveball,
Your shotgun analogy is amusing and by your statement I guess we're going to take everybody's shotgun because the # of people maimed and killed by shotguns is much higher than dog attacks.

My point had to do with matching owner's ability to handle dog with the dog's energy.

Of course large dogs (pits, Rotts, Shepherds) all have very strong bites (PSI) and will therefore cause more injury.

I have been bitten by more small dogs poodles, Bostons etc, who bite and the owner usually says, "he was just nipping, or he was playing". In my job I worked with the animal warden and I can assure you that the majority of dog BITES are not by Pitts!! (so you know the numbers are based on percentages of Pitts vs other dogs and further by dogs under 20 lbs).

Anyone making the argument about a dog being bred or in their "genetics", please remember that ALL dogs were ferrel, wild, pack animals that were slowly domesticated by humans. So drop that argument unless you're willing to euthanize little Fi-Fi as well!! Humans have evolved as well. we ate more fruits and vegetables and very little protein (when available). We have evolved to the unlimited carnivors that we are today, that consume enormous quantities of food!!!

Please be a responsible human and only raise the animal that is right for you. Maybe you can't have an animal.

Remember, all dogs are animals, have teeth and have the potential to bite. It's OUR RESPONSIBILITY to control our animal.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Bill Jones

6:59 am on Friday, August 10, 2012

Pit bull defeners always talk about bites. Sure, all breeds of dogs have the capacity to bite. We are not talking about bites. We are talking about maulings, mamings and killings. I have challenged people many times to find numerous reports of maulings, mamings and killings by other breeds. Since they can't, they usually go on to another specious argument about how sweet their pit bull is or some other irrelevant, poorly considered argument.

All one has to do is google "pit bull attacks owner". Or, "pit bull attacks 2012" for more recent articles about vicious attacks by these animals. There is an article practically every day regarding some vicious attack by a pit bull on a family member, friend, neighbor or stranger or their pet. You can't get this kind of search result for any other breed. And that is just a fact for all you pit bull lovers who seem to love facts. Or pretend to, anyway.

It is also important to remember that all pit bull attacks do not get picked up by the press. Just like every murder doesn't. So these are only the vicious attacks that are reported. No doubt there are many, many more that go unreported.

Bill Jones

7:11 am on Friday, August 10, 2012

Here are some of the most recent attacks by pit bulls. Googe them or yourself. You won't get such a result for any other breed. Oh, it's media bias. Yeah, big, coordinated, wide spread conspiracy.

Jul 31, 2012 – MIDDLETOWNCops kill pit bull after dog attacks its Middletown owner.— A 32-year-old city woman was airlfited to Westchester ...

Aug. 2, 2012 ... Police shot and killed a dog described as a pit bull/boxer mix Wednesday, after it attacked a woman and cat inside her car...

August 01, 2012 ,9-year-old girl attacked by pit bull in Plainfield Township credits rescuers for saving her life.,

August 5 2012 10:32 AM EDT2012-08-05 ... A 10-year-old girl is in the hospital after a pit bull attacked her near her home.

Aug 06, 2012 A woman is in the hospital after being attacked by two pit bulls Sunday morning. ... ... the pit bull owner, was charged with

August 7, 2012 A 60-year-old man jumped the fence at Hanford Place in Norwalk to escape a pit bull attack,.

August 8, 2012. ATLANTA - Police shot and killed a pit bull that was attacking a 2-year-old child in Atlanta on Tuesday.

August 8, 2012 ... Pit Bull Attack Puts Anchorage Woman in the Hospital ... The Anchorage Animal Control, who currently has two pit bulls up for ...

Aug. 9, 2012 | 3:49 p.m. ... Vallejo police shot and killed a pit bull Tuesday night after officers say it attacked a 5-year-old boy and his

This only a sample. Facts are stubborn things.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Wien

9:50 am on Friday, August 10, 2012

"Facts" from a Google search aren't exactly stubborn considering most news outlets couldn't even properly identify a pit bull. It's been pretty clearly shown by both proponents and opponents that "pit bull" is the news synonym for any large dog that bites. Not to mention everyone who second-hand reports to police that they've been bitten say they were bitten by a pit bull. I don't own a pit, rather I've had three lab mixes (all over 60 pounds) mixed with various large breeds including boxer and ridgeback - yet everyone asks me if they're pit bulls. Seems like a simple thing to get the breed of the dog right in a report - no? Just like most people can't properly discern between Muslim sects and call everything "Islamic terrorism" because it makes for good generalization and good ratings, most people can't properly discern between dog breeds...even those in rescue organizations who do it daily.

If pit bulls are such indiscriminate killing machines, wouldn't you expect pit bull rescue societies to have a high number of attacks and fatalities to their volunteers? Yet they don't. Wouldn't you expect Michael Vick's former dogs to be completely unable to be fostered and adopted? Yet they were, with the exception of one animal, adopted and fostered without issue to date.

People who use news reports as "facts" completely miss the other fact that you can use Google (and statistics) to say anything you want.

Comment_arrow

Christina Mays

1:33 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

It's true. The media doesn't want to report the other dog attacks. I did a paper in school on dog attacks. In Florida there were two different dog attacks on the same day. There was a "pit" attack with minor injuries that 11, yes 11, news outlets reported on. There was a Golden attack that ended up with the child needing over 200 stitches. Only 2 media outlets reported that attack. Another type of dog attack just isn't "sexy" news.

Comment_arrow

Support Pit Victims

4:17 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

Wien, when a breed of dog attacks and/or kills someone and a police report is written up, an animal control officer is called in to identify the breed and that is included in the report which is given to the news media.

Bill Jones

7:12 am on Friday, August 10, 2012

Pit bulls are the sweetest, most docile, loving and playful dogs there are . . . until they're not. Then reality sinks in. But by then it's too late and either the owner, a family member or neighbor has to bear the physical and mental anguish for the owner's ignorant, stubborn or downright stupid denial of the fact that these dogs have the very real potential to be unpredictably vicious.

Too many owners of these dogs have had to learn this fact the hard way. Sadly, there are numerous hard-headed owners of these dogs that only see the good side of them, which blinds them to the harsh reality.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Christina Mays

1:39 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

So the millions of responsible pit owners that have never had an incident with their pet are just hard-headed and delusional? You just the breed based on the few that make the media? So racial stereotypes are a good thing in your happy world? I have known hundreds of dogs that never bit anyone or shown aggression. So that is my imagination? I'm in denial because I have personally owned dozens of dogs that have never had issues? I've worked with hundreds more that likewise were trained and socialized correctly and that makes me ignorant of the breed? Wow, you must have had thousands of dogs to base your opinion on your vast knowledge....

Comment_arrow

Chris Balduc

2:58 am on Saturday, August 11, 2012

Christina... Millions??? No I don't think so. Pits make up only 5% of the dog population. You need to look at statistics, not ancedotial evidence to support your assumptions.
http://pitbullattacks.org/

MrsBee

7:28 am on Friday, August 10, 2012

One too many child in the UK has lost it's life to pit bulls, as a result they are now rightfully banned in my home country. It's a fact. While I appreciate that not all pit bulls are killers, the fact is this breed, of all breeds, has a history of attacking and killing humans - regardless of how well-trained or "in-control" the owner thought they were. Biting is one thing, mauling a child to death is quite another. I never quite understand these "misunderstood pit bull" articles.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Lorenzo Poe

3:11 am on Wednesday, August 15, 2012

Meh, so are guns. I know that you 'feel' a lot safer, but are you?
Course we love and cherish our freedom, which is why we are no longer a part of your 'happy' little country.

Bill Jones

8:24 am on Friday, August 10, 2012

"How did they become so maligned in today's society?

By attacking, mauling, maiming, hospitalizing and kiling people with monotonous regularity. Doesthat help you?

Reply
Comment_arrow

Buck

9:16 am on Friday, August 10, 2012

you're doing a great job Bill! 10 more inane comments on here and all the pit bulls disappear!

Comment_arrow

Bill Jones

9:49 am on Friday, August 10, 2012

It is common for pit bull owners/defenders to attack the indvdual making the points against this breed as opposed to attacking the points being made. The reason is that the facts are incontrovertable. Additionally, it shows that one has lost the debate, have become emotional and frustrated when they resort to personal attacks against the person they are debating as opposed to offering countervailing points, which you cannot.

Comment_arrow

Wien

9:53 am on Friday, August 10, 2012

Facts would be incontrovertible if "facts" indeed existed. However, as shown by the half dozen studies linked in these comments - there are "facts" and statistics to support both sides.

Not to mention the broad brush silliness of "monotonous regularity" - you'd think with such monotonous regularity that the issue would solve itself. There'd be no more pit bull rescue organizations or ASPCA shelters once this vicious animal maimed and killed all their volunteers with monotonous regularity. Give me a break.

Comment_arrow

Christina Mays

1:40 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

I've read about three deaths this year due to dog attacks. None were actual pit bulls. Should we just ban all large dogs just to be safe?

Comment_arrow

Support Pit Victims

3:48 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

Christina, I found 11 pit bull fatalities for this year so far:
http://www.dogsbite.org/dog-bite-statistics-fatalities-2012.php
There are other dogs represented here, but pits make up the majority of killers.
Should we ban pit bulls just to be safe?

Comment_arrow

Christina Mays

7:06 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

@support pit victims, you are using dogbite.org which is slanted against pits. If you can find valid, honest, cooberating evidence to support that, I will believe it.

Comment_arrow

Chris Balduc

3:01 am on Saturday, August 11, 2012

Christina, dogsbite.org tabulates and records dog attacks from ALL breeds, not just pit bull breeds. If you bothered to check my link you would have noticed that.

Bill Jones

9:03 am on Friday, August 10, 2012

"Pit Bulls are not for everyone, and typically not the best fit for the first-time dog owner. They are intelligent, energetic and strong-willed dogs who need consistent leadership from their owner, a commitment to their training, daily exercise and socialization. "

If this is true then ALL dogs are "not the best fit for the first-time dog owner." Which breed, for responsible ownership, does not need " . . . consistent leadership from their owner, a commitment to their training, daily exercise and socialization. "? I would respectfully suggest all dogs need this. The inference is that this is more, especially or exclusively true with pit bulls. Why is this?

Pit bull owners/defnders always use the "responsible onwership" argument after yet another mauling, maiming or killing by a pit bull. So, if emphasis on "responsibilty" always accompanies the discussion then it must be that irresonsiblity, which could be as simple as a lack of understanding of the breeds' potential for viciousness, can, indeed, result in tragic conseqences. Which other breed can you demonstrate whe discussing its traits requires an explanation or responsibe ownership? Responsible ownership of ANY dog is expected. Why is it always more important to point this out with pit bull ownership? Shouldn' it go without saying that one needs to be a responsible DOG owner?

Reply

Bill Jones

9:22 am on Friday, August 10, 2012

"Gangs began assimilating Pit Bulls into their operations, and the dogs became guilty by association with this violent, criminal culture."

They found kindred spirits. Bird of a feather lock together.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Buck

9:38 am on Friday, August 10, 2012

Finally Bill allows the real root of his problem with these dogs to shine through: he really, really hates minorities, guys. I bet he has lots of interesting things to say about drugs and welfare too!

And it's "flock together," you mouth-breathing zilch.

Bill Jones

9:38 am on Friday, August 10, 2012

"This was a challenging story to write because it’s personal to me, and there are so many points I want to include. I’m the proud owner of the two Pit Bull pups that you see in the main photo. Both were rescued from abusive situations, and both are the sweetest dogs you will ever meet." Until they are not.

Darla Napora, one of the staunchest, highest profile defenders, apologists and proponents of pit bulls was mauled to death in her home by a pit bull she rised from a puppy. It can be reasonably assumed she was a "responsible" pit bull owner.

Sadly, like the writer of this article, she was mistaken.

Google Darla Napora to read all about her and her tragic death by a vicious attack from her pit bull, which she no doubt considered the "sweetest dog you will ever meet".

Reply
Comment_arrow

Support Pit Victims

2:28 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

A real tragedy, Bill! Darla was a committed advocate for pit bulls but ended up being the 'poster child' for the many innocent, caring pit owners who are mauled by their dogs. Her husband had the dog cremated and buried with the remains of his wife and unborn child, always denying the dog was responsible for the deed. Goes to show the denial mentality of many pit owners. Folks can't be blamed for loving their dogs, but you have to put the welfare of people first.

Isle D Belle

9:41 am on Friday, August 10, 2012

Recently my sister was walking her Cairn Terrier on her street (in Connecticut), when a pit bull ran out of its house through an open front door and attacked her and her dog. She screamed, alerting neighbors who also ran out, including the dog's owner and tackled the pit. Fortunately, she and her dog are OK. This is the 4th such attack under similar circumstances for this particular pit. The owners are known to be irresponsible and generally have a reputation in the community for being trouble makers, they are the grandsons of the former chief of police in her town, so nothing has ever been done despite previous complaints. As a result of this incident, after all the neighbors marched down to the animal control office with my sister to make a complaint, the pit's owners are finally being cited for their dog's and their problem. However, this dog clearly has established itself as a dangerous predator that attacks without provocation. My sister's street is full of little kids - over 50 of them live on her block - and they all play outside. It's a disaster waiting to happen. Until the dog is removed from the block, because the owners cannot be trusted to take appropriate action, every child, animal and adult on the block is in danger of being attacked by this dog.

Reply

Isle D Belle

9:44 am on Friday, August 10, 2012

Frankly, I don't care what responsible pit bull owners say. It's a breed that has been bred for aggressiveness, it doesn't belong in urban or suburban settings. I am all for statutes and ordinances that prohibit ownership in those settings.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Support Pit Victims

2:21 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

Agreed. In 1989 Denver, Colorado passed one of the strongest and oldest pit bull ban still in effect. The net result is that Denver is among the few major U.S. cities which have had no fatal dog attacks in the past 20 years, while killing fewer impounded dogs of all breeds per 1,000 residents than any other major city between the coasts, and killing less than half as many pit bulls per thousand human residents (.14) as Miami/Dade County, the animal control jurisdiction killing the next fewest pit bulls (.33). Miami/Dade also has breed-specific legislation prohibiting possession of pit bulls. Let the anti-BSL people chew on these facts!

Sally Spangler

9:54 am on Friday, August 10, 2012

Good morning to all here who have been commenting on Pit Bulls. Please read this morning's Washington Post on the subject of dog bites. It might be something you want to be aware of in the DC area. We might go back to the place where every dog was required to wear a muzzle while walking on a leash with their owner. It was the law when I was a teen back there in the early 1950s and then disappeared.

Reply

Jessy M.

10:38 am on Friday, August 10, 2012

Any dog can be raised to be bad, like children , no dog is born bad it all in a matter of how it is raised... I remember my aunt and uncle owning an amazing American Staffordshire terrier, who got into a scuffle with a Porcupine and this dog sat there and let her pull the quills out of his face. I have a Silkie that wont even let me clip his nails! As with ANY animal, when raised right by loving, caring and ATTENTIVE, owners pit bulls are amazing beautiful dogs. The sterotyping of a pit bull is no different than saying everybody from Jersey is a guido .... or all New Yorkers are sarcastic a-holes... or anyone from the south is a toothless redneck....

Reply
Comment_arrow

Support Pit Victims

2:13 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

You can't compare a pit to a child, a pit breed has no moral standards, only the instincts of a dog and the traits bred into it. Pits are not natural breeds, they have been selected for the gameness and viciousness required to kill other dogs. You can be the most loving dog owner in the world, but that is no guarantee a pit is not going to turn on you or someone else. This is a verified fact. Google Darla Napora

Annie Brown

10:53 am on Friday, August 10, 2012

Why do people value their right to own a dog over the human right to life? If you could ensure that all pitbulls would be handled correctly that would be different, but you can't. The only difference between leaving a loaded gun on the porch and leaving one of the many breeds of proven aggressive dog breeds (the pitbull being one of them) on the porch, is that if a defenseless person, chid, etc comes across them, especially away from their owner, the gun isnt going to chase them down. You may be able to secure your dog and they may be sweet and lovin so far, untested, but the so many others can't, don.t or won't

Reply

Annie Brown

10:58 am on Friday, August 10, 2012

I m sorry, but some dogs like the pitbull are bred for their aggressive behavior. Do your research, read, talk to people, then you will know that dogs are "born that way". Please don't be a nikko nutter.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Wien

12:40 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

To say dogs were "born that way" completely ignores their decades as service dogs and therapy dogs before the media proclaimed all big dogs that bite as "pit bulls." Also ignores their service in World War II and their use on TV shows featuring children. I guess the dogs who are "born" to kill would make a great service animal for the US military and childrens shows.

I'd also guess that these dogs who are "loaded guns" or "born to kill" would naturally attack, maim, and kill every pit bull rescue organization and ASPCA volunteer...yet the incidence of bites or attacks aren't any higher with pit bull rescues than any other rescue organization that takes in unfamiliar animals.

"Do your research, read, talk to people...," would be great advice if you told us where to look or who to talk to. Dogsbite.org? ASPCA? Owners? Media? Who should we talk to? Because the dogsbite and media would tell you every attack is perpetrated by a pit bull...but the ASPCA puts them on their magazine's cover with the subtitle 'great for children'. There's more than a few nutters in this conversation, and I can tell you they're not all on the pit bull's side.

Leesa E.

11:14 am on Friday, August 10, 2012

I don't worry about any dog...there are too many human monsters...anything in their hands becomes a weapon.

Reply

Jess

11:49 am on Friday, August 10, 2012

My brother was attacked by a Black Lab. My Rottie mix was attacked by a Collie. When I volunteered at the HS the only dog that was ever aggressive towards me was a Shepard mix. There are TONS of stories of other types of dogs that attack but why don't they get reported? Because of the media. I know this article will never change the minds of the haters (as seen in comments here) but, if the tables were turned and someone tried to take away something they loved, they would know how we feel. I have owned 2 Pit mixes. They have NEVER attacked anyone. Never showed aggression to anything.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Support Pit Victims

2:07 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

Do you always reason by anecdote? You aren't serious. If you believer there is a conspiracy by the media to cover up attacks by other breeds and blame pits, first you need to establish a viable motive and then you need to prove there is such a conspiracy. So your pits never attacked anyone? Great! If you smoke you may never get cancer. If you drive without your seatbelt on you may never have an accident. However, the fact is you are 10 times more likely to be attacked by a pit then any other breed.

Leesa E.

11:50 am on Friday, August 10, 2012

BTW - I've been bitten at the age of 8 by a pit (my fault)...you have to watch for the signs...my parents warned me to stay away from the dog (who had a bite history). I never blamed the dog/breed or was afraid of any dogs after - thanks to the help of my parents I've owned several so called "bad breeds", one of which my daughter grew up with. That dog passed recently (after being with us for 13 years) and it broke our hearts...she was the best dog..will never be another like her. My family will continue to adopt dogs that others won't but we don't ignore warning signs that a dog may be too much for us to handle. I agree with the article and everyone who has said it's an owners responsibility to train their pets and that any dog can attack and hurt someone. Albeit, that some dogs will cause greater damage. I suggest everyone watch the HBO Documentary (if you haven't already) - "One Nation Under Dog". It's not about one breed...it's about all of them.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Jess

12:15 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

People should also check out "Beyond the Myth". It is a very interesting documentary on BSL.

Comment_arrow

Support Pit Victims

2:34 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

So I guess it's common sense to say that if you can't look or act in a certain way around a pit or other aggressive dog, it's not safe to have in your home. Do I just tell my kids never to show fear or approach the dog in a threatening way and then you will be just fine? It defies good parenting, in my opinion to have any kind of dog like this in my home.

Skip Endale

12:12 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

"A man reloading his gun at 14441 Brookfield Tower Dr. accidentally shot his friend." I noticed the word dog is missing.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Bentley's BARKery

1:11 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

No, Skip, the words Pit Bull are missing! But i'm sure someone could re-write the article to say that "A pit bull gave a man a gun which accidently discharged, killing his friend."

Amanda Tokarzewski

12:16 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

This was a great article to read! I am a proud owner of a pitbull named Cisco, and we rescued him from Bombshell Bullies, located in Vernon Hills. Its sad that ignorant people (Annie Brown) shame these dogs, ANY dog can attack a human, not just pit bulls!! Cisco is the most loving dog, and i am proud to say, any dog i own from this point on will be a rescued pitbull.

Reply

Robert Haskins

12:29 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

Those damn pits...they're bred to kill people. Once again....prove it...someone please prove it! I don't mean some article by some weird right wing nut but an actual double blind scientic test taken from a significant sample group. Duh, there are none! FLASH, the news is controlled/owned by these organizations some are liberal some conservative, etc. if you gather your data from the news instead of scientific data I guess you don't believe in evolution either (even though the Catholic Church has recognized it).

Pits have incredibly powerful jaws. So do RIdgebacks and Boxers and several other breeds with shorter, wider jaws. When they bite, they do a hell of a lot of damage.

As I stated in previous posts I was a police K-9 handler. My dog bit 9 people (under my specific command). He also released on command. Took lots and lots of hours of training to get there---it's "bred" into a dog to bite something (I.e., attack it) until it quits fighting...that's ALL dogs. You must recognize that you are working with nature's creatures. I think that packs of wild dogs were here far before humans domesticated them? Who's really responsible for them? We took the land they roamed freely on.

Some of you folks are making a similar argument to the one I was told by my grandparents...about the Jews. Most famillies didn't make it. Filthy animals huh? You should have seen what Shepherds did to Jews in camps in WW II. I guess they should be banned by your thoughts too

Reply

Robert Haskins

12:37 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

By the way...I don't own a Pit. Never have. Since my service dog passed away I haven't had any dogs.

Reply

Curveball

1:15 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

Lots of anecdotes and surmise here. (And then there's the erudite whimsy from that great social philosopher Buck.) I posted a scholarly article by physicians yesterday.They're the ones who deal with dog bites/attacks. They believe pit bulls are the most dangerous by far. Police, whether keeping statistics or not, say the same based on experience. A long-time Fairfax County animal control officer (part of the police department) told me t he same.
Famous last words: "Gee, he/she never did anything like this before."

Reply

Support Pit Victims

1:53 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

"The media has been a driving factor in shaping America's perception of Pit Bulls, and their coverage has been widespread and overwhelmingly negative..."

The publication ‘Animal People’ did a study and found that reported attacks by pit breeds is consistent with their rise in popularity in the 1980’s.

“Pit bull advocates commonly argue that pit bulls are considered "vicious" because incidents involving them receive disproportionately heavy news coverage--but key word searches of the 1,216 newspapers archived at NewsLibrary.com found only one year in the past 30, 1987, in which coverage of pit bulls appeared to be more intense than was warranted by the frequency of either life-threatening and fatal attacks.
Pit bulls were not even mentioned in any of the 1,216 newspapers indexed at NewsLibrary.com from 1976 through 1979--but then the numbers of mentions leaped from two in 1981 to 98 in 1995, 162 in 1986, and 470 in 1987, coinciding with a series of sensational attacks.
From 1988 through 1998, the frequency of mentions was consistent at about the 1986 level, but then nearly doubled in 1999, parallel to the number of fighting dog seizures; remained at the new peak for about five years; and more than doubled again from 2003 to 2005, as the number of fighting dog seizures again climbed.
A record 631 articles mentioning pit bulls were published in 2006, through December 30, up from 626 in 2005.” - Merritt Clifton

Reply
Comment_arrow

Support Pit Victims

2:38 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

Do you reason by anecdote or by statistics? All dogs can be loyal heroes, but that doesn't justify, for example, having an aggressive breed in a home. Study the numbers:
http://www.fatalpitbullattacks.com/

Kari Wright Warren

2:26 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

The top two "biters" are 1) poodle, and 2) chow. I discovered this after my daughter was bitten twice in one month a few years ago. (Neither dog was a poodle or a chow.) I have known a few pit bulls. They were the most friendly and loving dogs...all because that is what their owner bestowed upon them. I agree that there is no bad dog...only a bad owner. Thank you for writing this article. This is a great breed of dogs. Now, if we can only eliminate the "breed of humans" that sacrifice them for the love of money and fighting!

Reply
Comment_arrow

Support Pit Victims

2:52 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

Kari, poodles, chows and most breeds nip at you because they are scared or confused. Sure they can bite and sometimes injure or even kill. But this is a very rare thing for these nanny breeds. Pit breeds (there are 4) don't bite, they maul. They clamp down on soft tissue with their powerful jaws, shake their necks vigorously to loosen it, and then tear it out. There is a good reason why these dogs are bred for fighting and killing other dogs. Please think about this before comparing the attacks of pits to other dogs.

Kari Wright Warren

3:42 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

Support Pit Victims, I had a chow (and he was the nicest dog in the world!). Pit Bulls are no different than any other breed of dog. It is in the way they are raised. If they are raised in a loving home, they are wonderful dogs. Unfortunately, some people tend to acquire these dogs for fighting or because they think is it the "in thing to do" and do not raise them correctly. The facts stand...poodles and chows are the number 1 and number 2 biters of all dog breeds. And, I do not discount the attacks of any dogs...I was mauled by a lab and nearly had my face ripped off--two plastic surgeries later, I still have scars. They are all "animals" and need to be treated as such. This, coming from a two-dog owner who thinks they walk on water!

Reply
Comment_arrow

Support Pit Victims

4:00 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

Please provide me with a link to your data. When you say that chows and poodles are biters, are you talking about frequency or severity of the bite? If you are talking about frequency of bites then you make sense because pit breeds only make up 5% of the total dog population. If you are talking about severity than you have to consider the fact that pit breeds are responsible for 56% of all fatal attacks in 2006-2009. One attack that pits use when attacking children is to grip their heads in their jaws and rip the scalp off.
http://blog.dogsbite.org/2009/11/collection-of-pit-bull-scalp-attack.html
Can your poodle or chow or even your lab do this? No, they cannot.

Comment_arrow

Sally Spangler

7:09 pm on Wednesday, August 15, 2012

I once got a lesson that all family dogs are not gentle towards people/children. While visiting a cousin many years ago. I noticed my cousin had a beautiful chow. I like dogs in general. The dog went behind the sofa and lay down, not paying any attention to me. I put my hand towards the dog. No warning, the dog growled and snapped. I got chewed out by my cousin to never touch her dog, as it did not like to be touched. About 15 minutes of does and don'ts. I don't touch strange dogs, including the bull mastiff living next door. Nice gentle dog when with his owner. The dog knows my smell. I do not touch the dog, just speak to him gently. The end. I still like dogs - but along here the dogs are meant for "keep away from this home" So be it!

Laura Winslow

4:37 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

Can someone who is a pit bill owner/rescuer tell me about how pit bulls do with other non-dog pets in the house? Cats and/or birds? I've wondered about rescuing a pit bull but did not want my other pets at risk...

Reply
Comment_arrow

Kathy

8:20 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

Check out "Sharkey the Pit Bull". Just do a search on U-Tube. See all the non-dog pets this Pitbull loves. Now Pitbulls, like many other dogs do have prey drive. That isn't to say they all do, many live with other animals. But not all dogs were raised that way. You check out Sharkey.

Support Pit Victims

5:00 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

Are pit bulls nanny dogs?
There is really no such thing as a “Nanny Dog”. The term was invented by J.M. Barrie in 1904 for his production of “Peter Pan”. Nana was portrayed by a St. Bernard and an Old English Sheep Dog.
Dog fighting became a recognized problem in the 1980’s. Breeders had been trying to generate a better image for a dog known best for its ability to kill other dogs. At that time the drug dealers and malcontents began to associate themselves with pits, making an already problematic dog worse by breeding them for the aggressive traits they carry today. Pit supporters rallied by creating and image of the dog as maligned. This is when your myth of the “pit bull as nanny dog” got started. People began adopting them in greater numbers out of sympathy for a “maligned” breed without realizing that genetically, their temperament was unstable.
From 2004 to 2010 59 US children were killed by the family's, babysitter's, neighbor's or friend's pit bull. Since the early 80’s, news reports of violent attacks by pits have made news. In the 12-month period of 2009, DogsBite.org recorded 726 pit bull attacks reported by the U.S. media. Property information was available in 696 instances. 65% (455) of the pit bull bites occurred off owner property and 35% (241) occurred on property.
http://pitbullattacks.org/
No sir, pits are not nanny dogs.

Reply

Curveball

5:32 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

The Army, Marines and Air Force prohibit pit bulls on their bases.
Sheesh, what do those folks know about danger and violence?

Reply

Christina Mays

7:15 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

Okay, I'm addressing everyone here that keeps using flawed stats in their arguments. The information is only as good as the source. Dogbite.org has a known bias. And it uses information from the media hype that is proven to be incorrect.
http://nationalcanineresearchcouncil.com/uploaded_files/tinymce/2010%20DBRF%20Report_Final.pdf
The National Canine Research Council uses real information. They investigate each dog related death. It takes them longer to produce the information because they get it themselves instead of just taking off the media hype-wagon. In 2010 they show 33 dog related deaths in the US. Out of which there were only 12 that could be linked conclusively to an actual breed. There were only 2 confirmed pit deaths. There were husky, American bulldog, Rotties, a "sled dog", a confirmed mixed breed, a wolf cross, a boxer and a Shepherd. There were 3 attacks by a pack of mixed dogs that even included dogs like spaniels. 3 of the attacks were by dogs that were never seen or located but the media called them pits all the same. 15 of the attacks were by dogs that were not determined by sight, owners, or even DNA to be any particular breed but the media called all but one pit bulls. That doesn't mean that none of them were pit bulls but on the one where they had the corpse, the DNA proved it wasn't a pit bull. If the information comes from the media, it is whatever they want it to say. Garbage in, garbage out.

Reply

Christina Mays

7:18 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

I urge you to look at this report, check out the detail, confirm the accuracy with the local law enforcement and then tell us what you find. Of course nothing anyone says will change your mind. It is already made up and you are determined to hate the pitties. That is your choice but don't use fake stats.

Reply

Curveball

7:57 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

Yeah, right.
(Only in the English language can two positives mean a negative.)
The National Canine Research Council was started by one pit bull lover and then sold to another, who now bangs the drum. Fake stats, indeed.
Check it out for yourself.
The Centers for Disease Control very conservatively monitored dog bites/attacks some years ago but eventually stopped doing so because of pressure from pit bull lovers. Can ya guess why? They were finding that more than a third of the attacks were by a certain kind of dog (variations of pit bull) that was only a much smaller percentage of the nation's dog population. Again, those were conservative estimates. It was really more than two-thirds.
Harrumph.

Reply

Kathy

8:46 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

I have had Pits for the last decade. I have loved them all. I have been a rescuer, an advocate and have volunteered for rescues. I have never loved a breed of dog like the Pitbulls. They have personalities like no other dog - wonderful and loving.
However, with that said.....one thing we all have to sit up and take notice of.....there are not "bad" dogs, but there are dogs bred who produce genetically questionable dogs. If you get one of these dogs, you can STILL BE a RESPONSIBLE owner. It just depends on how willing you are to make your life about this dog. Some of the Vick dogs went to Bad Rap in CA and they worked like hell to get those dogs to be who we see today.
The thing is......when you are breeding dogs JUST FOR MONEY, you don't care if dogs from the same litter are bred. You just want to make money selling them. If you breed like this, you are called a "backyard breeder". And you may be producing puppies that will have genetic issues. So we need to work on mandatory spay/neuter laws and high fines for those who continue to breed these dogs for money. It is not fair to people who adopt the ones who have been dumped in the shelters.
So I fight for spay/neuter, so that people stop breeding JUST for money.

Reply

Alek

9:45 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

Thank you so much for this article. People who probably never even met a pitbull hate it just because they hear all the horror stories in the news, but all the good things that Pitbulls have done get no recognition?! That's ridiculous....any dog can be aggressive and can attack. People act like it's just pits who attack people. It is not their fault. It is stupid and ignorant owners who do not take the time to educate themselves on how to properly train this dog. I got my first pet who is a pit as a rescue dog. He was three months, with cropped ears, who's ex owner had a house full of pits that he trained (abused) to dogfight. He also sold drugs. And my pup was suppose to start training at 4 months, but fortunately he was saved. I have 3 children and never had an issue with my dog. He loves us and we love him. He plays with the kids, has very good behavior, and is very friendly. My dog is now 2 years old and every time i take him out for a walk I have an elderly neighbor that says " Wow! That's the most vicious dog on the street. He will lick you to death! " lol.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Curveball

11:10 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

Don't trip over all those logical fallacies such as "any dog can be aggressive...." etc.
A pit bull compared to other dogs as far as aggressiveness and attacks are concerned is analogous to an assault rifle with a 100-round magazine compared to BB-guns.
Not only are pit bulls more aggressive (and unlike most dogs, they don't signal anger until they are in close range and begin the assault) they bite, hold on and shake, ripping away flesh and crunching bones.
A simple broken-skin bite mark and then done with it would be a relief.

Tonia D.

1:09 am on Saturday, August 11, 2012

I don't understand why certain people keep coming back here to argue their points. It is pretty clear that they are not going to change their minds. This is an article meant to inform and help show others another side of a breed that has been vilified. If you hate pit bulls, fine, go away and quit coming back here with immature insults. For those of us who would like to show our support for the breed and perhaps answer questions, great. Either way, both sides are accomplishing nothing by calling names and spewing hatred. Please share what you have to say and move on instead of arguing like children.

Reply

Nancy Lockner

2:04 am on Saturday, August 11, 2012

Educate the owners as to how to handle dogs. Spay and neuter your animals, Socialize, socialize socialize the animal . Stop the madness of BSL Right now they are working on legislation that states it is not a valid law.
Really is the owner not the breed. If you want to own a particular breed study up because they all have their little quirks. Pits make one of the best obedience trained dogs out there They want to please and most are clowns.
I had one for 13 years when her spine seized up from Arthritis I had to put her down. We have a 7 year old rescued pit now along with a 13 year old dobe/ lab mix. So folks we could argue all day there are those for and those against. What shouldn't be is vicious slandering stories about a specific breed.

Reply

Chris Balduc

3:09 am on Saturday, August 11, 2012

The majority of pit bull owners aren't raising their dogs to fight each other for sport, I think we can agree. But if Sweetheart gets out the gate and mauls a jogger, pit supporters reason he must have had a "bad owner". What did the owner do to "make" the dog aggressive and therefore brand him a "bad owner"?
1. Leave the dog tied to a rope on a tree outside all day?
2. Use a human hand as a chew toy?
3. Forget to close the gate?
4. Refuse to vaccinate or neuter the dog?
5. Vote GOP?
6. Feed the dog the wrong kind of food?
7. "Train the dog to be aggressive?¬" (WTF does that mean?)
8. Not walk the dog every day?
9. Not give it hugs?
What is the "bad owner" doing that owners of less aggressive breeds don't do? ALL breeds have bad owners, but the vast majority of maulings are from the pit bull breeds.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Sally Spangler

11:00 am on Sunday, August 19, 2012

Chris - in Fairfax County, to get a dog from the county shelter, you MUST DO # FOUR _ VACCINATE AND NEUTER THE DOG> AND YES< CATS< ALSO>

VOTE GOP _ Nope, not me. grin -

KP

6:43 am on Saturday, August 11, 2012

I kind of love you for writing this article. I've always said, the ideal situation would be to have no pit bulls or any other breed involved in dog fighting, but replace the sport with a fight-to-the-death ring for unscrupulous reporters who care more about ratings and readership than about reporting factual information. Now THAT I'd pay to watch.

Reply

Sally Spangler

2:05 pm on Monday, August 13, 2012

KP - dog fighting has been illegal for many years now. It is just that getting the dogs desires that were bred into them bred out of them. Of course, it helps if their owners treat the pet with love and kindness rather than mock fighting with them. Of course, the looks of the dogs are still a part of that fighting past. Maybe figure a way to change their overall appearance would help as far as us humans view the dogs.

Reply

Stephen Kosman

10:23 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

Sorry folks... But -- as someone whose kind-hearted and friendly whippet was senselessly mauled, attacked from behind as he dared to simply look at a female dog, from a male mixed-breed (pit) bull dog -- we cannot escape the strong tendency of Dog Aggression that runs through mixed and pit bull breeds. I agree that these dogs can be wonderful around people and even children, but you can't out love/train their innate aggression toward other dogs. I'm fine with private ownership, as long as insurance is carried and dog breeds deemed "vicious" (toward humans OR other dogs) are not allowed off-leash in public areas.

Reply

Paul Loudney

10:38 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012

Simple solution -- just have a few years where the breed maims and kills people and other dogs at the same or lower rate as other breeds, and the problem will take care of itself.

Reply

Kat

1:26 am on Wednesday, August 15, 2012

First, love you guys who bring politics into the dog ownership debate, as if that makes any difference, very classy.
Second, the nastiest dog I have ever personally owned was a Pappilion, and if I had bothered to check out the breed before I rescued him I may not have adopted him, because in the breed traits it describes them as "Little Napoleons", and that dog was tyranical, nasty, nigh on un-trainable. I had to muzzle him to have company, and drug him to take him to the vet. I kept telling myself I had to be a "responsible pet owner" right up to the day he turned on me and bit me, with my 2 yr old daughter standing only a few feet away.
I had him put down that night, because he sure as hell wasn't getting a second chance to maybe bite her.
Dogs have breed traits. We know this, we study them when we are looking for the right pet for us. You can say "But...nice!" and "But...Raised right!" all you want, but ultimately, unless you are not only a responsible owner, but the undisputed ALPHA of your pack, and you make sure your Pit knows it, you may face a tragedy.
I like big dogs, always have. Best dog I've ever had was a Newf/Border collie mix, huge boy, 110lbs of sheep herding, nanny dog. I was Alpha, tho, and he knew it.

Reply

Gumlegs

10:21 am on Wednesday, August 15, 2012

Two things: "Nipper," the dog in the Victor trade-mark is widely believed to be a Jack Russell Terrier (or sometimes a Bull Terrier-Fox Terrier mix). You omitted Buster Brown's dog, "Tige."

Reply

JeskaMae

12:37 pm on Wednesday, August 15, 2012

I own a bully breed and I own a chuahua mix, guess who has bitten people in that mix? My chuahua, he has stranger danger and bites anyone who tries to pick him up, he's adorable so this happens frequently. My bully has never bitten anyone, I have pictures of my nieces growing up with him and crawling all over him and he hasn't bitten them. But my chuahua has bitten both my nieces as well as my bully, but my bully has never attacked my hotheaded chuahua either. The reason pits are responsible for a lot of bites is because they are TRAINED to be mean by the humans they trusted.

Reply

NerdyBaldGuy

2:13 pm on Wednesday, August 15, 2012

I've rescued and owned dozens of dogs in my life. My wife and I are huge animal lovers. I used to believe that any dog can be trained or socialized to any behavior. We treat all of our dogs the same and try to bring them up with the right mix of discipline and love. However, in recent years, I've come to believe that a) even within purebreds, there is a relatively non-trivial bell curve of different behavioral characteristics. So, to put it differently, within a given breed, you will find most dogs behave near the "norm" for that breed, but there will always be outliers. b) some dogs simply cannot be "trained" to eliminate deeply in bred behaviors. So, for instance, we thought we could, through both positive and negative reinforcement, train our Jack Russell not to kill chickens. But if it's possible, it is beyond our skill level. Nothing we've ever tried has worked.Also, every Anatolian Shepherd I've known has been extremely aggressive to anyone it considers not one of its people. That includes a 1/2 Anatolian and 1/2 Great Pyrenees that we raised from a pup. Just like we raise and socialize all of our other dogs. One time my brother's family came to visit and my little niece came running up to hug me. We thought nothing about having Anna out there since she'd never been aggressive to us. Anna perceived this event as an attack on me and jumped snarling in front of me lunging at my niece. I caught her in time. But she never really trusted my niece after that.

Reply

Beth

11:02 am on Thursday, August 16, 2012

Someone posted early on to make sure to get an AKC registered dog. But that's no guarantee of anything. Anyone can buy two AKC dogs, breed them, and register them. That means backyard breeders, homeowners who know nothing about breeding, and puppy mills can sell AKC-registered dogs. It's a piece of paper.

For me it's a no-brainer - with milions of dogs (and cats) killed each year, I'd always choose a rescue or shelter dog. But for someone who wants a purebred from a breeder, do your homework and carefully research the breeder beforehand.

Reply

beth cebra

9:20 pm on Thursday, August 16, 2012

checkout the first face transpant victim whose lab tore its face off; pomeranians and jack russels have killed small children before. to a small child isn't ddog size irrelevant? any dog can bite and cause damage. hell, a cat can cause severe injury to a child. small "cute" fluffy dogs have torn off many a child face. by shear numbers alone, so called pits are one of the most popular ddogs in the nation, and less than 1% of them bite. labradors are one of your top biters year after year. re pits shaking when the bite - really? every dog does that! watcch your dog tear up a stuffed animal to get to the sqeaker! there are 25 breeds that are commonly referred to as "pit bulls" not including mixes. you mix a lab and boxer what are you gonna get? a pit bull looking dog. the general public can't properly identify a dog and short of doing a DNA test you don't know. as for BSL in Denver, guess whch breed hold the most bites now? labradors. a weimerwiner recently ripped my friends dog's ear off,my neighbor's boarder collie kills squirrels and cats in our neighborhood always; my friends daughter watched her two bunnies killed by the dalmation next store. animals have prey drives. they have since the beginninng of time. its not a "pit" thing. i have owned pits for 25 yrs and do pit rescue for 6 yrs and have never been biten once. they are amazing friendly goofy and the only dog i'll ever own. wow guess i'm lucky to be alive LOL

Reply

beth cebra

10:21 pm on Thursday, August 16, 2012

pits also make amazing search and rescue as well as therapy dogs. i hope the ignorance people posting here don't ever find themselves in a position to need their help

Reply

Enjoy Life

10:29 am on Friday, August 17, 2012

I have a just turned 3 y.o. Plott Hound and people ALWAYS think he is a pit. He is the friendliest dog I have ever had (he is my 4th.) It is sad to see people's reaction to him sometimes...I know he can feel their tension and I would hate for that to give him a behavioral complex as he gets older. He is uber-friendly and playful and all he wants to do is play with every dog or human he comes in contact with. Dogs can read us more than most people realize. If your tense it makes them scared too. Just sharing.

Reply

Bob Parr

5:30 pm on Friday, August 17, 2012

Chicago man mauled to death by his own pit bull
By Andrew Mach, NBC News

Chicago police said the autopsy shows that 44-year-old Charles Hagerman was attacked and killed by at least one of his two pit bulls. Hagerman’s wife, Charlotte Williams, found him unresponsive with one of the pit bulls on top of him in their apartment around 8:15 p.m. Wednesday.
Williams ran outside and called police on her cell phone. When police arrived, Hagerman was pronounced dead at the scene.
Hagerman reportedly suffered multiple injuries from the dog attack, including a fatal neck injury, according to the autopsy. The death was ruled accidental, officials from the Cook County medical examiner’s office said.
“His wife was just sitting there in shock, just staring off into space,” Alameen said. “She said, ‘The dog killed my husband.’”
The family had owned the three-and-a-half-year-old pit bull, Scrappy, since he was a puppy, Charlotte Williams’s son, Daryl Williams, told the Chicago Sun-Times. They took in a second pit bull, Scrappy’s son, Rocco, a year and a half ago.
Daryl said the dogs were familiar and friendly with all three members of the household, which is what made the attack so puzzling. He said the incident has traumatized his mother, leaving her inconsolable and unable to sleep.
“Nobody knows,” Daryl said of how and why the pit bull attacked. “The dogs slept at the foot of their bed. He played with my nieces and nephews. We can’t figure this out.”

Reply
Comment_arrow

Bob Parr

10:39 am on Saturday, August 18, 2012

"All Dogs Bite?" There is a difference between biting and killing. Please post a link to the article "All Dogs Rip Their Owners' Throats Out" as happened in this case. Think you can find that story?

RareDiamondGem

7:58 pm on Monday, August 20, 2012

Don't mean to burst any ones bubble nor create controversy or be a pain in the butt but this RCA/His masters voice was not a pitbull but a fox terrier called Nipper. All our lives we thought this too! But Info should be corrected for readers! Here is the history link on Wikipedia. Ps. We do support Pit bull BSL laws strongly! http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/His_Master's_Voice

Reply
Comment_arrow

Dan S.

10:56 pm on Tuesday, August 21, 2012

You didn't create controversy, you proved the point of the article. You won't be able to understand this though, since having "strong" support of BSL is a mindless, racist point of view.

Sally Spangler

10:01 am on Wednesday, August 22, 2012

Way back there in 1943 - My family was living in Norfolk, VA. There was by some quirk - a pair of medium size dogs, mother and son who were behind a three foot picket fence. I think I can still describe the pair - white, pipe clay colored, small dark eyes, whippet like tails and absolutely smooth short fur. The story was out along the block that these dogs were "mean" dogs. I had a cross breed, long hair, black and white with a flag of a tail. Of course, because "Mickey" ALWAYS CAME when called - I had not put him on a leash. Mickey decided this time when I called him to me to "grin" and stay just far enough from me that I could not catch him. Down the street we went, mickey abou five or more feet in front of my on my bike. We went past the picket fence. One of the two white dogs was outside and up against the fence checking? just looking? at Mickey and myself. I got desperatte to catch Mickey by his collar and get him home. Mickey just danced around me, grinning. I finally sat down on the curb and cried. Mickey stopped dancing and came to me, licking my face. I hugged him and we got home safely. The dangerous white dog stayed behind its fence. I was terrified by the knowledge that the white dog was "dangerous", It did not jump its fence it just followed our gyrations. End of story. Pit Bull? Staffordshire Terrier? Do not know. I was terrified.

Reply

Bob Parr

10:05 pm on Saturday, August 25, 2012

All cats bite. Anyone who says tigers are any different from housecats is prejudiced.

Tiger at German zoo kills keeper, is then shot dead
Reuters
This male Siberian tiger, seen on March 8, killed a zookeeper in Cologne, Germany, on Saturday.
By NBC News and wire reports
BERLIN -- A Siberian tiger attacked and killed a female keeper at Cologne zoo on Saturday before being shot dead.
The gate of the tiger's enclosure had not been properly shut, allowing the big cat to jump on the woman and maul and bite her, a zoo spokesman said.
The director of the zoo, Theo Pagel, shot the tiger from a rooftop, the spokesman added. Police briefly cleared the area after the incident but the zoo later reopened for visitors.
The victim's name was not immediately released but she was said to have been 43 years old.
"This is the darkest day of my life," Pagel later said in a brief statement at the zoo's entrance, the Kolner Stadt-Anzeiger news website reported.
"I shot and killed the animal so that we could enter ... and take a look. But the employee was already dead," he added.
"We cannot yet explain how the keeper could make such a fatal mistake (of failing to close the gate)," Pagel said.
The Cologne zoo in western Germany, founded in 1860, is one of the oldest and best-known in the country.
Reuters contributed to this report.

Reply

Sally Spangler

12:26 am on Sunday, August 26, 2012

Bob, the only cat to bite me is/was the one I now have over the 50+ years I have had one or more cats. I have a beautiful golden tiger. A few consistent "NO" has broken the habit. If she has decided that out of my arms is where she wants, she just might show she is going to bite, "NO Biting" and she pulls back. No claws either, She knows that "paddy-paws" means no scratching. A wild animal is a wild animal. Even if it has been caged all of its life. It may generally not offer claws or teeth, but most keepers of such know that the chance of being bitten or clawed CAN HAPPEN. They watch the animal's face and eyes and wha the tail is doing. A waving/whipping tail, ears that are not facing forward, a semi-crouch and probably a undertone of a growl. Means trouble is present and will happen unless the human pulls back. Be in the cat house at the National Zoo when the cats are being fed. The keepers are careful! Some cages, the food is slid under the bars in a certain place so that the cat can't reach the man feeding it. You will see the same thing happen in the large ape cages. If the animal doesn't want contact with the food provider - hey the keeper knows it.
You like dogs, OK - not like cats? OK. Some dogs, of any age and type are one person dogs. They like one person in the house and stay away from everyone else. Why? any explanation is good enough.

Reply

virginia

10:32 am on Thursday, September 6, 2012

Wow there is certainly a lot of opinions on this post, some I agree with and some I dont. In America we are allowed to have our opinions. The sad thing here is ignorance and discrimination. We have all had our experiences with many breeds of dogs, its how we walk away from that experience that matters. I dont judge anyone particular breed of animal, nor would I do that of a human. That in part is probally by the way I was raised. I do own 2 pit bulls. Before I owned them I heard the good and bad stories, but I decided for myself that I wanted to take a chance, no matter what I have heard. My two pits have given me the greatest enjoyment. They are loving, sweet, loyaly and to strangers they may have to endure being licked to death. If I am sick, or recently loss a family member, they sense my sadness and climb into bed with me and follow me every where I go. Without them I would probally not have faired so well during some hard times. I take them in public, and most people pet them, but I still get some awful looks. Once they approach them, they are pleasently surprised. I love my pit bulls and have had many breeds of dogs. I hope those who have had a bad experience can walk away without ignorance of the breed or any breed for that matter. It is each persons choice to pick any breed. No matter which one, I hope they give the love and attention any animal deserves. My final thought here is, " Dont discriminate one or a few for the whole group." Punish the Deed, not the Breed.

Reply

Mike Rogers

5:55 pm on Monday, December 3, 2012

Most of the problems associated with pit bulls has nothing to do with the breed. It has to do with the type of person who would want to own a pit bull in the first place. It's a status thing and a statement pit bull owners feel they are making to everyone else. It's sad, really. Nobody has any practical purpose for a pit bull other than to have one as some sort of status or personality symbol.

I know, I know. All you pit bull owners are going to get mad at me. I'm not lumping you all into a single group. A friend of mine owns a pit bull and she's one of the sweetest things I've ever met (not as sweet and gentle as my lab mix though!). Even the most responsible pit bull owner has to admit, though, that there are a large number of pit bull owners who own them for the wrong reasons and that's why people get hurt. No?

Of the hundreds of different pure breed mixes and the thousands of mixed breeds available, why do people still insist on purchasing a dog with a violent history when they live in a suburban neighborhood? Makes absolutely zero sense for the dog or the owner.

Reply

James

9:47 pm on Monday, December 3, 2012

I have no idea I have 3 stinking cats.

Reply

Leave a comment